jack bogle thesis pdf

• Princeton University Undergraduate Senior Theses, 1924-2023
• Economics, 1927-2023

Items in Dataspace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.

• Get 7 Days Free

Was Bogle’s Princeton Thesis Eerily Prescient?

Eric Balchunas, senior ETF analyst for Bloomberg Intelligence, describes the Bogle Effect and the serendipitous shaping of the Vanguard founder’s career.

On this episode of The Long View , Eric Balchunas joins us to discuss the beginning of Vanguard and his latest book, The Bogle Effect: How John Bogle and Vanguard Turned Wall Street Inside Out and Saved Investors Trillions. Here are a few excerpts on the Bogle Effect and the storied history of Vanguard and Bogle's career from Balchunas' conversation with Morningstar's Christine Benz and Jeff Ptak:

The Bogle Effect

Benz: So, Jeff referenced that your book is called The Bogle Effect, and you've referenced this in your remarks so far. But what is the Bogle Effect, in your opinion? Balchunas: I used to use the phrase where I think—I still do—the Vanguard Effect. When you see Schwab lower their fees and then BlackRock and Fidelity, it's sort of all a byproduct of Vanguard and having to compete with them. So, we used to call that the Vanguard Effect. And as I explored this book, I had a few different titles in mind. But I wanted to put his name first and foremost, because I felt like without this guy himself none of this would have happened. And then, obviously, with the Vanguard ownership structure was very unique. So, those two things I thought were the core catalysts to all the change we see. Index funds merely a byproduct of that initial core. And the effect is just generally the ripple effects across all of the industry. And as I just mentioned before, it's well beyond index funds. Obviously, Vanguard has active funds. The passive funds are actually changing the way other active funds behave. It's getting more concentrated so they can complement Vanguard. Vanguard is getting into wealth management. Wealth management has them getting into private equity. So, you go on and on, and you realize that this is going to be a big deal for a long time. It's not just a passive thing or an index fund thing. And so, I really wanted to put the spotlight on Bogle's character and uniqueness and the structure's uniqueness and build from there and give that the credit for the explosion that is going to continue to ripple out through the whole enchilada.

Pivotal Moments in Bogle’s Past

Ptak: In the book you trace Bogle's life career and long arc. So, I wanted to focus for a moment on the early stages of his life and career. Bogle, he came from what had been a wealthy family, but he didn't lead a life of privilege as a young person. How do you think those early life experiences set him on his future course? Balchunas: I think they were pivotal. I think a couple of things maybe later were equally as pivotal. But obviously, your childhood is major. First of all, he was always working. He was a scholarship kid. He had a taste or a sniff of the Great Depression. I always tell people, like especially my mom and my family, I would say, "Visiting Jack Bogle was like hanging out with my grandfather, not my father." He was not a boomer. He was a World War II-type guy. He had the same sense of humor. The office had like pictures of warships and stuff, just like my grandfather. And that generation was very thrifty generally. They had just seen things that the rest of us haven't. And I think he had enough of that that was a nice core for him. And obviously, working off of scholarships, he had to work, doing all kinds of jobs, including setting bowling pins. And in my life, as I've met people who had to work through college, they tend to be the most successful people. That's a really good ethic to begin with. So, I think thriftiness was important. Obviously, that paid dividends later. And in fact, I do think there was some genetics at work though. His great grandfather was a populist fighter of insurance companies. And Bogle lists some of his great grandfather's speeches in one of his books. And it's fascinating how similar their language is. His great grandfather was the one who said, "Gentlemen, cut your costs." He just copied it. So, there was some genetics at play, I believe, and of course, obviously, the environmental aspects that I said as well. And I think his father was not a great achiever; he didn't achieve a lot and had trouble holding down a job. And I think that also probably sparked Bogle to want to make something of himself.

Bogle’s Princeton Thesis

Benz: The academic thesis that Bogle wrote when he was a Princeton undergraduate was eerily prescient. Can you talk about the main thrust of the argument he made in that thesis? Balchunas: It really is something how the seeds of Vanguard are in there. Basically, he wrote this thesis that says something along the lines of future growth can be maximized by reducing sales charges and management fees. Funds can make no claim to superiority over the market averages. And the principal role of the investment company should be to serve its shareholders. That's pretty good. That definitely gives some credence to the way Bogle wrote the rest of his life, because circumstance definitely played a big part, but Bogle would put himself as the hero. And some people will push back against that, and there's definitely some truth there. But those core statements are pretty much the foundation of Vanguard. A lot of things had to happen first, but they're right there. And one interesting tidbit about the Princeton thesis—two of them. One is, he was looking for an idea for the thesis in the library at Princeton. He didn't know what he was going to write about. And he picked up Fortune. And there was an article on mutual funds in that magazine. And it was deep in the magazine, and it wasn't on the cover. You had to be curious to get it. I think his curiosity and reading a lot helped him a lot in his life. In addition, I looked at what was on the cover of other magazines at the same time and Time magazine at the time had Conrad Hilton on the cover. So, I do imagine what if he picked up Time instead? It's interesting how two different paths—he maybe had been a low-cost hotel guy. But the other thing that's interesting is Michael Lewis—I interviewed him for the book—and Michael Lewis has a binder he keeps. And when I told him this, he goes, "Wow. I got to print that out because I have a binder that I keep of Princeton thesis that have changed the world." I'm not sure if he is planning to write a book about it. But the atom bomb was first devised in a Princeton thesis; Teach for America. And there's this history of Princeton thesis having a lot of things that were seeded right there that became actual major accomplishments or events or ideas that formed.

The Serendipitous Start of Bogle’s Career

That's fascinating. You mentioned serendipity and the role that it played in his choice of thesis. I wanted to talk about another somewhat odd confluence of events. This one took place when Bogle was working for his first employer, which was Wellington Management Company. Can you talk about what happened when Bogle was working there and how that, in essence, brought Vanguard into being?

I'll try to keep this as short as possible because it is a long story literally. And part of the challenge of writing this book was to condense this so I didn't bore the non-nerd people. And I kept rewriting this section, so my mom understood it. Because you can get lost in the weeds here with structures and mutual funds versus the investment advisor. But the long story short is, Bogle in the ‘60s was given control of Wellington by his boss at a young age. So, he was running Wellington at age 35. And they were having problems, because in the ‘60s, it was like this past decade where the arcs of the world were crushing it, and boring investors were really having a tough time. And Wellington was more on the boring side. It was conservative. It was a balanced fund. And so, in order to, as Bogle puts it, "I was selling nutritious bagels, but everybody wanted donuts." He figured he'd have to sell donuts.

So, he went over and looked out to partner with an equity manager. And it's interesting. He went through a bunch that said no—Capital Group, Franklin—and I think the fifth or sixth one that he chose was Thorndike, Doran, Paine and Lewis. And they remind me a lot of ARK. They were a high-flying growth manager that was just crushing it. Some of those stocks like Xerox back in the day were like the Teslas of their day. And so, for a while, it worked. It was a good partnership. The flows started coming back in. But then, the bear market hit. And these guys had a real falling out. And I think Bogle felt like he had betrayed his mentor and the company by selling out and giving these other hotshot growth managers too much power in their partnership. They had effective voting control. So, they got into a fight, fingers were pointed, and basically, they fired Bogle.

And so, instead of going off and licking his wounds, like I probably would have done, he basically fought back, and he found a little leverage, which was that he was still the president of the mutual funds themselves. And so, there's this wonky detail that the mutual funds are like shell companies, and the president of those funds actually had some control over—they're like general contractors; they can decide who is doing what role. So, he used that leverage to basically dig in and fight with them. Over the next couple of months, they had a lot of, they called the bifurcation period, and ultimately, the board of the fund said we need a solution. So, Bogle had to come up with a solution that would make everybody happy and somehow pass the board, which had some of his new partners on it, but also some of his older Wellington people who are fans of Bogle, but it had to be unanimous.

Anyway, long story short, what they decided and what Bogle came up with, was the idea to create a back-office company that would just do the boring stuff that Wellington didn't want to do. And they wanted to manage money; OK, fine, you do that. We'll keep you as investment advisor; we'll do all the back-office stuff; I'll run that company. And by the way, we'll make it mutually owned. That way, nobody thinks I'm trying to get out of here and put a bunch of money in my pocket. And so, that's how Vanguard was born as the sort of boring, mutually owned back-office company. And it was just a way to save his job in a way and appease all these different parties so they would be able to resolve this nasty, really unusual situation. I think you're right that that is very serendipitous. And I think it was a great study in just how sometimes the best things come from the worst experiences, and I would say this is a great example of that.

This article was adapted from an interview that aired on Morningstar's The Long View podcast. Listen to the full episode .

More on this Topic

The Best Index Funds Looking for low-cost index funds to invest in? These mutual funds and ETFs earn Morningstar’s top rating for 2024. Tori Brovet

How to Find a Great Dividend Fund Plus, seven funds rated Gold or Silver that investors should consider adding to their portfolios. Daniel Sotiroff

Sponsor Center

• Side Hustles
• Power Players
• Young Success
• Save and Invest
• Become Debt-Free
• Land the Job
• Closing the Gap
• Science of Success
• Pop Culture and Media
• Psychology and Relationships
• Health and Wellness
• Real Estate
• Most Popular

Related Stories

• Power Players Shaquille O’Neal says this advice from Jeff   Bezos got him to invest in a startup
• Power Players Mark Cuban: Here's the moment I knew I   wouldn’t succeed in corporate America
• Pop Culture and Media Tom Holland's 'seven-figure' 'Avengers'   bonus once got sent to the wrong actor
• Pop Culture and Media The unusual promise Margot Robbie made   Ryan Gosling to get him in 'Barbie'
• Startups How a 36-year-old with 'little experience'   built a $2 billion marketing company

Investor Jack Bogle founded his legendary company based on his Princeton senior thesis

Jack Bogle, who died yesterday at age 89, was one of the world's greatest investors. The founder of investment company Vanguard Group, he was known by many as the "father of index investing." His decades-long success had a unique start, however: a thesis he wrote as a college senior at Princeton.

"Were there no Princeton, there would be no Vanguard," Bogle explained at an address at Princeton in 2004.

Since the 1929 market crash wiped out his wealthy family's fortune, Bogle attended college on a scholarship.

Though Bogle had snagged good grades at the preparatory school Blair Academy, he found Princeton tough. A low point came in the fall of 1948 when Bogle struggled to pass an economics course taught by Paul Samuelson, a Nobel Laureate in Economics.

Bogle said he often struggled to maintain anything above the equivalent of a C average. He put his energies into his senior thesis to keep his scholarship and leave Princeton on a high note.

Determined to write his thesis on a subject no one else had tackled, he took to one of Princeton's many libraries for research. That's when, in December of 1949, Bogle discovered an issue of Fortune magazine.

He paused on an article titled "Big Money in Boston" that described the mutual fund industry, one it said was "tiny but contentious." The piece focused on a company called Massachusetts Investors Trust, one of the first of these companies, according to Business Insider .

The article said that the industry could be very influential and that it could be the "ideal champion of the small stockholder." The description caught Bogle's attention and he decided on the spot to pursue the topic further for his thesis.

Bogle would spend countless hours researching and analyzing the industry. In the end, he earned a top grade and graduated Princeton magna cum laude. "It was a delightful, if totally unexpected, finale for my academic career at Princeton," he said at the 2004 talk.

The resulting 130-page paper reached key conclusions that would lay the groundwork for Bogle's career and investing philosophy, he explained in a 2013 essay for the Journal of Portfolio Management .

Some of these ideas included the argument that mutual funds "may make no claim to superiority over the market averages" and "future growth can be maximized by reducing sales charges and management fees."

The paper also led to an important mentor. Walter Morgan, a 1920 Princeton grad and the founder of the Wellington Fund, read his thesis and later agreed to hire him. "Largely as a result of his thesis," he said to his staff at the time , "we have added Mr. Bogle to our Wellington organization."

That job helped launch his professional career. "He gave me the opportunity of a lifetime," said Bogle .

Bogle's ideas were contrary to the thinking of the time, an article in Kiplinger explained today, but shaped Vanguard, the firm he'd later found, with a "new way to fund a company." Lower fees, the magazine said, would help attract investment dollars and "gain traction" over existing rivals.

While Bogle's philosophies were mocked at first by the investment management industry, his common sense approach to investing would earn him a place among the most influential investors.

Even Warren Buffett would count Bogle among his personal heroes, saying his approaches helped "millions of investors realize far better returns on their savings than they otherwise would have earned."

Bogle retired from Vanguard in 1996, but continued to be an advocate for investors. He often spoke on investing topics and would eventually write 13 books.

His first book even earned a forward by economist Samuelson, the professor in whose class Bogle struggled at Princeton so many years ago.

In his most recent book, " Stay the Course: The Story of Vanguard and the Index Revolution " published just last fall, Bogle said his early thesis was steeped in idealism.

Six decades later, he wrote, that idealism had "hardly diminished."

We will keep fighting for all libraries - stand with us!

Internet Archive Audio

• This Just In
• Grateful Dead
• Old Time Radio
• 78 RPMs and Cylinder Recordings
• Audio Books & Poetry
• Computers, Technology and Science
• Music, Arts & Culture
• News & Public Affairs
• Spirituality & Religion
• Radio News Archive

• Flickr Commons
• Occupy Wall Street Flickr
• NASA Images
• Solar System Collection
• Ames Research Center

• All Software
• Old School Emulation
• MS-DOS Games
• Historical Software
• Classic PC Games
• Software Library
• Kodi Archive and Support File
• Vintage Software
• CD-ROM Software
• CD-ROM Software Library
• Software Sites
• Tucows Software Library
• Shareware CD-ROMs
• Software Capsules Compilation
• CD-ROM Images
• ZX Spectrum
• DOOM Level CD

• Smithsonian Libraries
• FEDLINK (US)
• Lincoln Collection
• American Libraries
• Canadian Libraries
• Universal Library
• Project Gutenberg
• Children's Library
• Biodiversity Heritage Library
• Books by Language
• Additional Collections

• Prelinger Archives
• Democracy Now!
• Occupy Wall Street
• TV NSA Clip Library
• Animation & Cartoons
• Arts & Music
• Computers & Technology
• Cultural & Academic Films
• Ephemeral Films
• Sports Videos
• Videogame Videos
• Youth Media

Search the history of over 866 billion web pages on the Internet.

Mobile Apps

• Wayback Machine (iOS)
• Wayback Machine (Android)

Browser Extensions

Archive-it subscription.

• Explore the Collections
• Build Collections

Save Page Now

Capture a web page as it appears now for use as a trusted citation in the future.

Please enter a valid web address

• Donate Donate icon An illustration of a heart shape

John Bogle on investing : the first 50 years

Bookreader item preview, share or embed this item, flag this item for.

• Graphic Violence
• Explicit Sexual Content
• Hate Speech
• Misinformation/Disinformation
• Marketing/Phishing/Advertising
• Misleading/Inaccurate/Missing Metadata

plus-circle Add Review comment Reviews

33 Favorites

Better World Books

DOWNLOAD OPTIONS

No suitable files to display here.

IN COLLECTIONS

Uploaded by [email protected] on December 2, 2013

SIMILAR ITEMS (based on metadata)

John Bogle on Investing: The First 50 Years by

Get full access to John Bogle on Investing: The First 50 Years and 60K+ other titles, with a free 10-day trial of O'Reilly.

There are also live events, courses curated by job role, and more.

T HE P RINCETON T HESIS

A S I RE-READ MY thesis “The Economic Role of the Investment Company,” from cover to cover, three things struck me. First, it wasn't too bad! While the quality of the writing was hardly first-rate, it seemed quite serviceable and comprehensible, especially considering that I was a not-particularly-mature young man but 21 years of age, and that it was my first major writing project. The organization seemed about right too, and the research—in a field where data were scarce—remarkably complete. * I'm not sure that I would place the thesis in the high honors category, but I surely reveled in that outcome all those years ago.

In retrospect, I wish that I had done more research on the extent of the mutual fund industry's success in serving investors, and, in particular, that I had evaluated fund investment performance more comprehensively. First, I accepted at face value the industry's claim that, as cited in my thesis, “the attainment of objectives is proof of good management,” and ignored the perhaps inevitable vagueness of most funds’ goals. (It's difficult to refute a claim, as made by one fund that I cited in the thesis, of having provided “reasonable dividends, profits without undue speculation, and conservation of capital,” worthy as those objectives are.) But the kind of comparative data we take for granted today were then almost three decades away. ...

Get John Bogle on Investing: The First 50 Years now with the O’Reilly learning platform.

O’Reilly members experience books, live events, courses curated by job role, and more from O’Reilly and nearly 200 top publishers.

Don’t leave empty-handed

Get Mark Richards’s Software Architecture Patterns ebook to better understand how to design components—and how they should interact.

It’s yours, free.

Check it out now on O’Reilly

Dive in for free with a 10-day trial of the O’Reilly learning platform—then explore all the other resources our members count on to build skills and solve problems every day.