essay on third home rule bill

Home Rule: The Third Home Rule Bill

  • The Third Home Rule Bill

In 1912 the Third Home Rule Bill passed the House of Commons. The most notable difference from the bill of 1893 was that it would have eventually given control of the police to Ireland. A tremendous outcry arose in Protestant Ulster, which feared Roman Catholic domination. Private armies—the Ulster Volunteers (in the North) and the Irish Volunteers (in the South)—were raised, and civil war threatened if the bill became law. In 1914, Commons again passed the bill, but the House of Lords excluded Ulster from its provisions. The Commons voted to allow Ulster to vote itself out of Home Rule for six years. At the outbreak of World War I the bill was passed once again with the proviso that it should not go into effect until after the war. The law never took effect.

Sections in this article:

  • Introduction
  • Home Rule in Contemporary Northern Ireland
  • The Irish Free State and the Fourth Home Rule Bill
  • The Second Home Rule Bill
  • The First Home Rule Bill
  • Origins of the Home Rule Movement
  • Bibliography

The Columbia Electronic Encyclopedia, 6th ed. Copyright © 2024, Columbia University Press. All rights reserved.

See more Encyclopedia articles on: British and Irish History

sandbbox logo

Today in 1913 the Third Home Rule Bill passed the House of Commons

Chances of home rule remained strong in ireland just three years before the easter rising..

Leader of the Home Rule Party and master organizer, John Redmond.

On January 16, 1913, the third reading of the “Government of Ireland Bill” more commonly known as the Third Irish Home Rule Bill was passed through the House of Commons in London.

Two weeks later it was to be once again rejected—for the third time—by the House of Lords who aligned with the Unionists—living mainly in Ulster— and feared that the introduction of Home Rule would spell a break up for the union of Ireland and England.

For once, this rejection in the House of Lords did not spell a journey back to the drawing board for the advocates of Home Rule in Ireland. With thanks to the Parliament Act in 1911, the House of Lords no longer had the power to defeat a bill, simply delay it, meaning that Home Rule was still to be implemented but with a bit of a wait.

The Home Rule Bill was a piece of legislation that would remove the governance of Ireland from England and return it to Ireland. Following a failed rebellion involving French assistance in 1798, the Act of Union, 1800, was put in place, essentially meaning that the Irish no longer engaged in a personal union with England with the Protestant Ascendancy ruling over the country from Dublin, they were now ruled directly from London.

READ MORE: Irish political cartoons from Home Rule period acquired by Great Hunger Institute (PHOTOS).

Attempts to repeal this union began immediately with “The Emancipator”, Daniel O’Connell fighting for its end throughout the 1840s.

Earlier this week , we saw the anniversary of his first public speech arguing against the Act of Union to a group of Catholics in Dublin in which he declared that it would be better to return to the days of the Penal Laws than to spend any more time in such a union with England.

"Let every man who feels with me proclaim, that if the alternative were offered him of Union, or the re-enactment of the Penal Code in all its pristine horrors, that he would prefer without hesitation the latter, as the lesser and more sympathizers proclaimed to the Catholic meeting on January 13, 1800, “that he would rather confide in the justice of his brethren the Protestants of Ireland, who have already liberated him, than lay his country at the feet of foreigners."

READ MORE: Today in 1800 Daniel O'Connell made his first speech opposing Union with England.

The concept of Home Rule, however, only came to popular attention in Ireland in the 1870s, following further failed uprisings in 1803, 1848, and 1867.

In 1870, Isaac Butt, a barrister and former Tory MP, founded the Irish Home Government Association. Using a cross section of progressive landowners, tenant rights activists, and supporters and sympathizers of the failed Fenian uprising of 1867, Butt and the association evolved into the Home Rule League who earned the alliance of many Irish MPs.

The movement would be revitalized yet again with the introduction of the master organizer Charles Stewart Parnell as leader, turning the Home Rule effort into a powerful political force from parish to parliament level.

By the time it finally passed in 1913, it was the third time a Home Rule Bill was brought in front of the English Houses of Parliament. The first came in 1886 under the Liberal government of Prime Minister William Gladstone with the support of Parnell and the Irish Parliamentary Party. The Bill did not even pass the House of Commons.

The second attempt came in 1893 with Parnell recently deceased and although it passed the House of Commons, it was rejected in the House of Lords.

It wasn’t until 19 years later under Herbert Asquith’s Liberal government that the bill returned. For two general elections, Asquith and his party had held onto power by forming alliance with the Irish Nationalist Party and its leader John Redmond . A condition of this alliance was to finally deliver on Home Rule for Ireland.

The Bill was successfully passed through the two houses at the beginning of 1913 because of the reduced powers of the House of Lords.

Unfortunately for the Home Rule party, the outbreak of the First World War in 1914 sent the British government into emergency mode and the Home Rule Bill was once again placed on the long finger.

With the promise of its immediate implementation at the closing of the war, John Redmond delivered a rousing speech to Irish Volunteers in which he encouraged them to support the British cause against Germany.

As a largely Protestant country attempting to assert their power over smaller Catholic countries, many were happy to obliges to fight against Germany and many even enlisted in the British Army to fight in the trenches.

There was a minority, however, who were unhappy with the English once again not meeting a demand and felt that Redmond was weak in bending to another excuse instead of implementing Home Rule on time. Among this minority were the leaders of the 1916 Rising who were not prepared to wait any longer to regain power from Britain.

Seeing WWI as England’s difficulty and Ireland’s opportunity, they organized the 1916 Easter Rising , a failed uprising that none the less rekindled the flames of rebellion among the Irish people and is being celebrated this year as one of the most significant events on the road to Irish independence.

The Home Rule Bill was never to be.

Irish political cartoons from Home Rule period acquired by Great Hunger Institute (PHOTOS)

Celtic Thunder sets sail on ODYSSEY: A North American Tour, tickets on sale next week

Celtic Thunder sets sail on ODYSSEY: A North American Tour, tickets on sale next week

Uncovering Irish American history at Notre Dame

Uncovering Irish American history at Notre Dame

Irish giant folklore might be explained by genetic study

Irish giant folklore might be explained by genetic study

essay on third home rule bill

Ireland in spring - your guide to bucket list travel and spectacular festivals

WWII ship where five brave Sullivan brothers died discovered on St. Patrick's Day

The intersection of Saint Patrick and paganism in Ireland

TUNE IN: St. Patrick’s Day Parade LIVE from Dublin today!

US leprechauns versus Irish fairies - a St. Patrick’s Day death match

NYC Saint Patrick's Day Parade announces line of march ahead of March 16

St Patrick's Festival is here! Your guide to the Dublin City celebrations

Sober St. Patrick’s Day to “reclaim the day” today in NYC

“Walking in the footsteps” of your Irish ancestors

We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

  • Temperature Check
  • The Stardust Inquests
  • Inside The Newsroom
  • Climate Crisis
  • International

essay on third home rule bill

Explainer: The Third Home Rule Bill is 100 years old today. What did it do?

A SMALL NUMBER of events are being held across Ireland today to mark the centenary of the Third Home Rule Bill – legislation which is seen by many as essentially being the first legislation thta ultimately created the Irish state we know today.

But what was that bill – and why is it considered so momentous? Let us try to explain the history behind it all.

We should start with the basics.

In 1800 both the Parliament of Ireland (as it was then) and the Parliament of Great Britain passed the Act of Union, legislation which merged the Kingdom of Great Britain and the Kingdom of Ireland into the United Kingdom.

The countries had (partially) shared a head of state since 1541 – when Henry VIII quashed Silken Thomas’ rebellion and upgraded Ireland from a Lordship to a Kingdom, and proclaimed himself King of Ireland.

If at first you don’t succeed…

The Act of Union, which kicked in in 1801, remained in effect throughout the 19th century, despite a number of Irish nationalist movements – with Charles Stewart Parnell successfully convincing the then-prime minister, William Gladstone of the Liberal Party, to table a bill which would have undone most of the Act of Union, recreating a Kingdom of Ireland with its own parliament (albeit one with limited power) – a concept called ‘Home Rule’.

Despite Gladstone’s appeals – culminating in a now-famous three-hour speech to the House of Commons – this Home Rule Bill was defeated by 341 to 311 in June 1886, thanks largely to the rebellion of 93 backbench Liberals who opposed the Bill because Gladstone had drafted it in secret and without their input.

Bruised by the rebellion of his MPs, Gladstone called a general election later that month and lost power. He returned in 1892 and gave it another crack – but again decided to draft his bill in secret, even excluding his own ministerial staff and cabinet from having any input.

Despite this, the bill cleared the House of Commons in September 1893, but it was already being seen as damaged goods. Gladstone’s secret drafting had resulted in a catastrophic financial error, massively underestimating how much money Ireland should contribute to the British budget, while tensions between the Conservatives and the nationalist Parnellite wing of the Irish Parliamentary Party resulted in regular fist-fights on the opposition benches.

When the Bill was then sent to the House of Lords, the Conservative majority – being firm supporters of Unionism – was in little mood to be open-minded. The Lords obliterated the Bill by 419 to 41 and the movement was defeated again.

Change at home…

In the meantime, though nationalist feelings remained high in Ireland, British politics underwent larger changes. A dispute arose in 1909 when the Liberals – again in power – had a Budget passed by the House of Commons but blocked by the House of Lords (which due to its make-up had a firm Conservative majority), a move considered a break with precedent.

Two general elections were held in 1910 in an effort to allow the public to decide whether the Liberals or Conservatives should prevail, each with inconclusive results. In the end, the only way the Liberals could hang onto power was to strike a deal with the Irish Parliamentary Party, exchanging the support of the IPP’s 74 MPs for a new attempt at introducing Home Rule.

What followed was a fundamental shift in the British political system: knowing that the only way to break the Conservative majority in the Lords was to flood it with new lifelong Liberal members, the Liberals secured the support of King George V to appoint hundreds of new peers and ensure their majority.

The Conservatives backed down – happier to keep their majority in a weakened House of Lords than to give up their stranglehold on power – and the Liberals pushed through new laws which meant the House of Lords could no longer veto legislation, but only delay it. The Lords could now only vote against legislation twice: if the Commons approved it three times, it would be sent straight to the King to be signed into law.

With this done, prime minister Herbert Henry Asquith presented the Third Home Rule Bill to the House of Commons on 11 April 1912 (100 years ago today). That bill created a bicameral parliament, with a 164-member House of Commons and a 40-member Senate, and also allowed Ireland to continue electing MPs for Westminster (though the size of Irish constituencies would become far larger, meaning fewer MPs).

Although the Lords continued to oppose it – and with significant opposition from Ulster-based Unionists, who feared becoming a powerless minority in a country led by Dublin and not the more industrial Belfast – the Commons successfully passed the Bill three times.

…and abroad

There was only one problem: by the time it was passed a third time, and could be sent to the King, there was a bigger issue on the horizon – the United Kingdom was now part of the Great War.

Assuming that the war would be brief, Asquith rushed through a new Suspensory Act which put the provisions of the Home Rule Bill and another law, giving Wales an independent church, on hold until the end of the war.

The legislation was then overtaken by events. The Great War rolled on and on, and nationalism instead expressed itself through the Easter Rising of 1916. Britain then opted to try and implement Home Rule immediately, but agreed not to do so unless an agreement was reached on the status of Ulster within the new jurisdiction.

As World War I continued into 1917 and 1918, Britain found itself short of manpower and tried to link Home Rule to mandatory conscription – something rejected by all nationalist parties – and when the US joined the war, averting the crisis, the conflict was soon ended.

A blank page

But with the Liberals now having kept power for over eight years, and having delayed elections until the end of the war, a general election was called. The Irish Parliamentary Party lost almost all of their seats to Éamon de Valera’s fledgling Sinn Féin, whose members boycotted Westminster and formed their own revolutionary assembly. That assembly became the First Dáil, and declared an independent country called the Irish Republic, a move which led to the Irish War of Independence.

In 1920, the still-not-enacted Third Home Rule Bill (now known as the Government of Ireland Act 1914) was replaced by a Fourth Home Rule Act which partitioned Ireland into two jurisdictions, Northern Ireland and Southern Ireland.

Elections were held to the parliaments of both countries, but De Valera’s Sinn Féín rejected Britain’s right to pass laws for the Irish Republic. Sinn Féin ran candidates in the new election, but those candidates formed the Second Dáil instead.

Eventually a truce was called in the War of Independence, and the Second Dáil sent a team led by Michael Collins to negotiate what became the Anglo-Irish Treaty, which the Dáil ratified by 64 votes to 57.

The outcome was the creation of a 26-county Irish Free State – which slowly excluded the role of the King and eventually became the modern Republic of Ireland we know today – and the Irish Civil War, fought between supporters and opponents of the Treaty.

Read:  Anthem composer and tricolour creator honoured at Glasnevin

Making a difference, a mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation..

For the price of one cup of coffee each week you can make sure we can keep reliable, meaningful news open to everyone regardless of their ability to pay.

essay on third home rule bill

To embed this post, copy the code below on your site

600px wide <iframe width="600" height="460" frameborder="0" style="border:0px;" src="https://www.thejournal.ie/https://www.thejournal.ie/explainer-what-was-the-third-home-rule-bill-being-celebrated-today-414508-Apr2012/?embedpost=414508&width=600&height=460" ></iframe>

400px wide <iframe width="600" height="460" frameborder="0" style="border:0px;" src="https://www.thejournal.ie/https://www.thejournal.ie/explainer-what-was-the-third-home-rule-bill-being-celebrated-today-414508-Apr2012/?embedpost=414508&width=400&height=460" ></iframe>

300px wide <iframe width="600" height="460" frameborder="0" style="border:0px;" src="https://www.thejournal.ie/https://www.thejournal.ie/explainer-what-was-the-third-home-rule-bill-being-celebrated-today-414508-Apr2012/?embedpost=414508&width=300&height=460" ></iframe>

One moment...

  • Defamation Damaging the good reputation of someone, slander, or libel.
  • Racism or Hate speech An attack on an individual or group based on religion, race, gender, or beliefs.
  • Trolling or Off-topic An attempt to derail the discussion.
  • Inappropriate language Profanity, obscenity, vulgarity, or slurs.
  • Spam Advertising, phishing, scamming, bots, or repetitive posts.

Create an email alert based on the current article

essay on third home rule bill

comscore

Impact of 1912 Home Rule Bill recalled

The decisive impact of the third home rule bill on the history of ireland over the past century was the theme of the first official….

THE DECISIVE impact of the third Home Rule Bill on the history of Ireland over the past century was the theme of the first official event to mark the 1912-1922 decade of commemoration which took place in Waterford City Hall last night.

The event highlighted the role played by John Redmond, leader of the Irish Party in the House of Commons, who was MP for Waterford from 1891 until 1918, in the creation of modern Ireland.

Minister for Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht Jimmy Deenihan, who is co-ordinating the commemorative events, said the decade that began with the introduction of the Home Rule Bill in April 1912 remained the most momentous in our modern history.

“Nobody could have foreseen the tumultuous events that would unfold in the following years: the attempts to compromise, the displacement of constitutional politics, the mobilisation of the Volunteer movements, arms importation and the postponement of implementation for the duration of the Great War, by which time the issue had been overtaken, not least by the events of 1916,” Mr Deenihan said.

He said the century that followed was greatly influenced by the historic events of those years and national progress was still being shaped by those developments.

“The centenary anniversaries of the Home Rule Bill and the other events to follow in these coming years present an opportunity for us all to reflect on the experience and achievements of a remarkable era.

“It is my sincere hope that there will be a broad interest in our commemorations and explorations,” he added. “The centenary anniversaries present an opportunity to address our shared history together, with the benefit of all the progress in political and community relations of recent years.

“I hope that we will also have the benefit of the research by historians, supported by their examination of official records and other archives made accessible only in recent times.”

The Minister said the polarisation in the decade after 1912 had not been kind to the legacy of John Redmond, but he quoted from contemporary Cork journalist and writer John Horgan on the Irish Party leader’s legacy: “His reward was to be repudiated and denounced by a generation which had yet to learn . . . that true freedom is rarely served by bloodshed and violence and that in politics compromise is inevitable.”

The chancellor of the National University of Ireland Dr Maurice Manning said the founding fathers of the State were, for the most part, men of 1916 – WT Cosgrave, Éamon de Valera, Richard Mulcahy, James Ryan, Desmond FitzGerald and Seán Lemass.

“The two parties which dominated and shaped the new State were both born of old Sinn Féin and both, maybe in slightly differing ways, saw 1916 as the founding event of the modern Irish State. However much else has changed over the years, that view has not changed,” Dr Manning added,

While some scholars and commentators had questioned that interpretation, the inescapable fact was that 1916 was the central seminal date in the history of modern Ireland.

“The importance of this event is not that it challenges that view – it does not – but it is a reminder at this very early stage in this decade of centenaries of just how complex our history is; that it is not a monochrome but a tapestry of different colours, a web of strands, traditions and personalities, of people who looked at our country, at what it meant to be Irish and what was best for Ireland in very different ways and frequently came to very different conclusions.”

For 40 years, Dr Manning said, the Irish Party was the voice of nationalist Ireland and for 40 years, its goal was an independent Irish parliament. “It educated and socialised generations of Irish people into the workings and values of parliamentary democracy and made enormous gains in land reform, universities, education and local government.”

Historians Frank Callanan and Dermot Meleady detailed events surrounding the Home Rule Bill and Redmond’s life up to 1912. Minister of state for Northern Ireland Hugo Swire MP responded.

Stephen Collins

Stephen Collins

Stephen Collins is a columnist with and former political editor of The Irish Times

IN THIS SECTION

‘make no mistake and remember, the stardust changed every person it touched’: witness testimony was startling and distressing, stardust families were better resourced and more involved in latest inquests, ‘jesus christ, the doors are locked’: the full story of the stardust fire, with new testimony, tributes paid to veteran rté broadcaster and producer alf mccarthy, man accused of threatening to kill woman remanded in continuing custody, woman living ‘exotic’ lifestyle given four months to vacate home bought with crime proceeds, family affairs: how ireland’s newly rich are putting money to work in secretive firms, university changes gender identity policy that said refusal to use pronouns was ‘unlawful’, stardust inquests: unlawful killing verdicts returned by jury in each of the 48 deaths in nightclub fire, ex-eirgrid chief faces court action over ‘driving under influence of intoxicant’, latest stories, uk’s easyjet shares lift with strong summer momentum, man found guilty of dangerous driving causing death of gaa commentator paudie palmer.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Information
  • Cookie Settings
  • Community Standards

Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.

To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to  upgrade your browser .

Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link.

  • We're Hiring!
  • Help Center

paper cover thumbnail

8 THE THIRD HOME RULE BILL IN BRITISH HISTORY EUGENIO BIAGINI

Profile image of Eugenio F Biagini

Related Papers

Eugenio F Biagini

There is a paradox about the place of the 1912 Home Rule crisis in British history. On the one hand, it polarised opinion and brought the kingdom to the brink of civil war. On the other, twenty-first century observers struggle to understand why a bill that proposed a mild and conservative form of legislative devolution should have caused such violent responses. And it is not only our sceptical generation that takes this view: already in 1930 King George V, in a private conversation with his prime minister, J. Ramsay MacDonald, reportedly said: 'What fools we were… not to have accepted Gladstone's Home Rule Bill. The Empire now would not have had the Irish Free State giving us so much trouble and pulling us to pieces.

essay on third home rule bill

Mercier Press eBooks

Daithí Ó Corráin

Revue française de civilisation britannique

Pauline Collombier

Thomas Mohr

Emmet O'Connor

Journal of Legal History

This is the second of two articles examining the relationship between British Imperial statutes and Irish law in the early years of the self-governing Irish state. The present article examines the assertion that the Imperial parliament at Westminster enjoyed the right to legislate for the self-governing Irish state in the 1920s and 1930s. Successive governments in the Irish Free State

Sean Mallen

Journal of British Studies

Irish Studies Review

Connal Parr

RELATED PAPERS

Makalah Istishab

rezar adi permana

Advanced Healthcare Materials

Grace Bushnell

Mouseion: Journal of the Classical Association of Canada

Jeppe Gustafsson

Ioannis Papamichail

Kelly Soares

Revista Contrapontos

Maria Laura Brenner de Moraes

Behice Ekici

Δελτίον Χριστιανικής Αρχαιολογικής Εταιρείας

Ευθύμιος Τσιγαρίδας

Clive Shrubsole

Complex &amp; Intelligent Systems

Sunil Pratap Singh

Annals of Epidemiology

Nobuo Nishi

Physical Review Special Topics - Accelerators and Beams

Port Said Scientific Journal of Nursing

Inti Revista De Literatura Hispanica

Olbeth Hansberg

British Journal of Surgery

Sigismond Lasocki

Ajax Moreira

Fitri Anggriyani Sitinjak

Mike Korinek

Lecture Notes in Computer Science

Tatsuaki Okamoto

Physical Review C

Ricardo Francisco Fariello

Journal of Bone and Mineral Research

Nicolas Bochud

Revista da Sociedade Brasileira de Medicina Tropical

Ana Marassá

RELATED TOPICS

  •   We're Hiring!
  •   Help Center
  • Find new research papers in:
  • Health Sciences
  • Earth Sciences
  • Cognitive Science
  • Mathematics
  • Computer Science
  • Academia ©2024
  • Accessibility Options
  • Select language Language English Gaeilge
  • Collections & Research
  • Event Calendar
  • Visitor Info
  • Exhibitions
  • Upcoming Events
  • Engage & Learn
  • Visitor Information
  • 3D Virtual Visit
  • Press & Media Information
  • Accessibility
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Archaeological Licensing
  • iCAN - the Irish Community Archive Network
  • Art and Industry Collections
  • Art and Industry Collections List
  • Easter Week
  • Discover the historic Asgard yacht
  • Current: 1912-1914: Ireland, the Asgard and the Home Rule Crisis

1912-1914: Ireland, the Asgard and the Home Rule Crisis

In its early years, while the home rule crisis developed in ireland, the asgard was used as a cruising yacht by erskine and molly..

Ireland in 1912 was in a state of political turmoil. A Bill to grant Home Rule to the country was once again being debated in Westminster. On two previous occasions in 1886 and 1893 the Home Rule Bill failed to get through both houses of parliament. In 1886 the Bill had failed to get through the House of Commons, the 1893 Bill was passed by the Commons only to be decisively defeated in the House of Lords. At this time the House of Lords had the right to veto any act of parliament indefinitely, and this combined with the fact that it was dominated by the Conservative party seemed to ensure that Home Rule would never be passed.

The Parliament Act 1911

However in 1909 a crisis developed which would resulted in the power of the House of Lords being limited. In that year the Lords attempted to block the budget from being approved. This represented a violation of the traditional role of the Lords, and resulted in the government taking steps to affirm the dominance of the House of Commons over the Lords. To do this they needed the support of John Redmond's Home Rule Party, which was only too keen to see the curtailment of the power of the House of Lords. The Parliament Act of 1911 stipulated among other things, that the Lords would only be able to block Bills from being passed for a period of 2 years. This could allow Home Rule to become a reality, in April 1912 the new Home Rule Bill was put before parliament, it was passed by the Commons, but rejected by the Lords. This would be repeated twice more over the following two years, but following the third rejection the government could use the provisions of the Parliament Act to bypass the House of Lords and send the Bill to be ratified by the King. By 1914 however, the forces opposed to the granting of Home Rule had mobilised creating a major problem for the government.

Unionism and the Ulster Volunteers

For the Unionist portion of the population prospect of Home Rule being granted was a very unwelcome development. Severing the link with Britain was seen as a threat to the religious liberty of the protestant population, and to the economic prosperity of the protestant dominated north-east of the country. There had been riots and acts of protest at the time of the previous Home Rule Bills, but with the inevitable prospect of Home Rule being granted in 1914, more organised and concrete resistance was planned.

In September 1912 over 200,000 men signed the Ulster Covenant pledging to fight the imposition of Home Rule in Ireland. In unionist communities across the north of Ireland small militia groups began drilling, and in January 1913 the Ulster Volunteer force was formally established. The Ulster Volunteers represented a major obstacle for the liberal Government in their efforts to introduce Home Rule in Ireland, they had the full support of the British Conservative party as well as many wealthy business interests in Ireland. With many ex-army personnel to aid in its organisation the UVF continued to drill during the summer of 1913 while the leadership raised money and made efforts to import arms for the movement.    

The Irish Volunteers

As the Ulster Volunteers drilled, many nationalists in the south became concerned that they might threaten the granting of Home Rule. There had long been a tradition of violent nationalism in Ireland represented in 1912 by the Irish Republican Brotherhood, but this had been secretive and marginalised since the emergence of the Home Rule movement. As more moderate elements within the nationalist camp came to see a need for an armed force to protect nationalist interests the more extreme nationalists were keen to get involved as this might afford them the opportunity to further their own objectives. Both the parliamentarian and Militant traditions of nationalism had benefited greatly from the growth of gaelic cultural organisations during the years prior to the introduction of the third Home Rule Bill. Many individuals became involved in politics through these organisations most prominently Eoin MacNeill and Pádraig Pearse. The different groups came together on November 25th 1913 to formally establish the Irish Volunteers with MacNeill as honorary secretary. Their stated aim was ‘to secure and maintain the rights and liberties common to all the people of Ireland’. The organisation attracted many members over the following months and began to drill. The forming of the volunteers was viewed with suspicion by John Redmond and members of the Home Rule Party, despite this, many Home Rulers also became involved.

Curragh Mutiny

As 1914 began, tensions were running high. The threat of violence when the Home Rule Bill came into force prompted the British government to look into using the army to suppress the Ulster Volunteers. This however prompted serious protests from the officers in command of the troops in Ireland. The army was a traditional bulwark of conservatism within the state and thus shared the views of the Unionists on the Home Rule question. Added to this many of the officers came from loyalist Anglo-Irish families. Consequently in March 1914 when the officers were briefed on the plan to move north to act against the Ulster Volunteers the majority choose to resign rather than obey the Governments orders. The incident became known as the Curragh Mutiny, though there had not actually been any insubordination, but the resignations did prompt the government to drop plans to use the Army to move against the Ulster Volunteers.                                     

Larne Gun Running

This episode had greatly boosted the confidence of the Ulster Volunteers who now proceeded forward in the belief that the army would not act against them. Major Frederick Crawford, a member of the Ulster Unionist Council with extensive military experience, had been tasked with organising shipments of arms for the Volunteers. Through an arms dealer in Hamburg he purchased 24,000 rifles and 3 million rounds of ammunition and arranged for them to be shipped to the north of Ireland. The arms were landed successfully at Larne, Bangor and Donaghadee on the night of 24 th /25 th April 1914 and hastily driven away in a fleet of assembled cars. Despite having knowledge of the plan the authorities took no action against these activities, this combined with the Curragh incident the previous month convinced the Irish Volunteers of the need to arm.  

Share this page

Sign up to our newsletter

Keep up to date

Receive updates on the latest exhibitions

National Museum of Ireland

Announcements.

We regret that the Asgard exhibition will be temporarily closed from Monday 15th to Friday 19th April

We regret that some of our Military History galleries at the National Museum of Ireland - Decorative Arts & History, Collins Barracks, Dublin 7, are temporarily closed for repairs

Our current restoration work means the first floor of our museum is closed. This limits our capacity so visitors should be prepared to wait in line outside for up to 1 hour

IMAGES

  1. The Third Home Rule Bill- Home Rule Crisis 1912-1914

    essay on third home rule bill

  2. (PDF) 8 THE THIRD HOME RULE BILL IN BRITISH HISTORY EUGENIO BIAGINI

    essay on third home rule bill

  3. The Home Rule Bill (Leaflet) (1914)

    essay on third home rule bill

  4. The Third Home Rule Bill, 1912 by Jack Morris on Prezi

    essay on third home rule bill

  5. 2) Third Home Rule Bill

    essay on third home rule bill

  6. The Home Rule Bill

    essay on third home rule bill

VIDEO

  1. HM Amit Shah speaking on National Capital Territory of Delhi(Amendment) Bill,2023 in RS (7 Aug 2023)

  2. Rule of divisibility by essay method

  3. The Lack of Third Spaces and Fandoms

  4. The 3ed home rule bill

  5. State lawmakers debate 3 high-profile money bills (Wednesday noon report)

  6. Andrew Bridgen

COMMENTS

  1. Third home rule Bill

    Third home rule Bill. The cause of home rule languished until the Liberals returned to government in 1906. In January 1910, H H Asquith - Prime Minister since 1908 - was forced to call an election because of an impasse with the House of Lords over the 1909 People's Budget. John Redmond, the new leader of the Irish Party, demanded that home rule ...

  2. 1912: Home rule and Ulster's resistance

    Wed Apr 25 2012 - 01:00. When the third Home Rule Bill was introduced to the Commons 100 years ago in April 1912 it seemed a triumphant vindication of the tradition of parliamentary constitutional ...

  3. The Home Rule Crisis 1910

    1910. Home Rulers hold balance of power after two elections Edward Carson elected leader of the Irish Unionists. 1911. Parliament Act passed. Unionists begin preparations against Home Rule. Resistance led by Edward Carson and James Craig. 1912. Introduction of the Third Home Rule Bill Unionists sign the Solemn League and Covenant. 1913.

  4. Home Rule Crisis

    The Home Rule Crisis was a political and military crisis in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland that followed the introduction of the Third Home Rule Bill in the House of Commons of the United Kingdom in 1912.. Unionists in Ulster determined to prevent any measure of home rule for Ireland and formed a paramilitary force, the Ulster Volunteers, which threatened to resist by force of ...

  5. Home Rule: The Third Home Rule Bill

    The Third Home Rule Bill. In 1912 the Third Home Rule Bill passed the House of Commons. The most notable difference from the bill of 1893 was that it would have eventually given control of the police to Ireland. A tremendous outcry arose in Protestant Ulster, which feared Roman Catholic domination. Private armies—the Ulster Volunteers (in the ...

  6. Today in 1913 the Third Home Rule Bill passed the House of Commons

    On January 16, 1913, the third reading of the "Government of Ireland Bill" more commonly known as the Third Irish Home Rule Bill was passed through the House of Commons in London. Two weeks ...

  7. Explainer: The Third Home Rule Bill is 100 years old today. What did it do?

    With this done, prime minister Herbert Henry Asquith presented the Third Home Rule Bill to the House of Commons on 11 April 1912 (100 years ago today). That bill created a bicameral parliament ...

  8. PDF 1912 Home Rule and Ulster's Resistance

    The drama of the Home Rule Bill was to be an extraordinary curtain raiser to a decade that changed the face of modern Ireland. When the Third Home Rule Bill was introduced to the Commons 100 years ...

  9. The Third Home Rule Bill

    Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. As part of our historical podcast series Conor Mulvagh looks at the Third Home Rule Bill. Listen to this Irish history podcast at History Hub.ie. The Third Home Rule Bill - 100 Years On.

  10. Bluff, Bluster and brinkmanship: Andrew Bonar Law and the Third Home

    The article attempts to show that Bonar Law had an effective and coherent strategy towards home rule. Previous interpretations have stressed his weakness and inexperience, either his 'pandering' to the extremists in the Tory party or his readiness to seek a compromise, when civil war began to loom large, in the autumn of 1913.

  11. (PDF) 2014 'The Third Home Rule Bill in British history', in Gabriel

    17 The Third Home Rule bill in British History Eugenio Biagini The Amending Bill [for the temporary exclusion of Ulster from Home Rule] & the whole Irish business are of course put into the shade by the coming war Herbert H. Asquith to Venetia Stanley, 29 July 19141 There is a paradox about the place of the 1912 Home Rule crisis in British history.

  12. DOCX Mr. McSweeney History Hub

    Using these three key points this essay will discuss how Irish society was divided by the Third Home Rule bill. Background to the Home Rule and the Third Bill The Bill was the third of its kind and was the first to be passed by the House of Commons, after two other separate bills were rejected; the first being defeated in 1886 and the second in ...

  13. Home Rule Bill*

    ANDREW BONAR LAW AND THE THIRD HOME RULE BILL* JEREMY SMITH Goldsmith's College, London ABSTRACT. The article attempts to show that Bonar Law had an effective and coherent strategy ... 8 Jalland, The Liberals and Ireland; Midleton papers P.RO. 30/67/56/3305 Sankey to Midleton, 23 Jul. I932. ' B.L.P. 34/2/39 Law to Sir H. Craik, i6 Mar. I9I4 ...

  14. 18

    Summary. Interpretations. The social crisis was overshadowed by a larger political crisis of the years 1910-14 which involved high politics in Westminster and high drama in Ireland. What distinguishes the third Home Rule episode from former controversies was the greater importance of the Ulster question, the threat of violence with which the ...

  15. Federalism, devolution and partition: Sir Edward Carson and the search

    Four days after the dramatic launch of the anti-home rule campaign at Craigavon on 23 September 1911, where Sir Edward Carson was 'delivered to his people', Fred Oliver, a keen Unionist, passionate federalist and peddler of various constructive political initiatives, wrote to Geoffrey Robinson, editor of The Times. In the course of a long and pessimistic letter he expressed deep distress ...

  16. History of Ireland 1893

    On 28 September 1912, Craig introduced the 'Ulster Covenant', which people could sign to pledge their determination to defeat the Third Home Rule Bill. It was a huge success and 450,000 Irish people signed it, some in their own blood. The week came to a climax on 28 September 1912, which was known as Ulster Day.

  17. Impact of 1912 Home Rule Bill recalled

    Thu Apr 12 2012 - 01:00. THE DECISIVE impact of the third Home Rule Bill on the history of Ireland over the past century was the theme of the first official event to mark the 1912-1922 decade of ...

  18. Home Rule

    The Home Government Association, calling for an Irish parliament, was formed in 1870 by Isaac Butt, a Protestant lawyer who popularized "Home Rule" as the movement's slogan.In 1873 the Home Rule League replaced the association, and Butt's moderate leadership soon gave way to that of the more aggressive Charles Stewart Parnell.Demands for land reform and denominational education were ...

  19. 8 the Third Home Rule Bill in British History Eugenio Biagini

    416 THE THIRD HOME RULE BILL IN BRITISH HISTORY Yet, it was not Gladstone, but Herbert H. Asquith, Winston Churchill, David Lloyd George and John Redmond who brought the Home Rule bill onto the statute book, and it was the 1912 bill, not those of 1886 and 1893, which nearly caused an army mutiny and civil war in the United Kingdom.

  20. Government of Ireland Act 1914

    The Government of Ireland Act 1914 (4 & 5 Geo. 5.c. 90), also known as the Home Rule Act, and before enactment as the Third Home Rule Bill, was an Act passed by the Parliament of the United Kingdom intended to provide home rule (self-government within the United Kingdom) for Ireland.It was the third such bill introduced by a Liberal government during a 28-year period in response to agitation ...

  21. 1912-1914: Ireland, the Asgard and the Home Rule Crisis

    This could allow Home Rule to become a reality, in April 1912 the new Home Rule Bill was put before parliament, it was passed by the Commons, but rejected by the Lords. This would be repeated twice more over the following two years, but following the third rejection the government could use the provisions of the Parliament Act to bypass the ...

  22. The Government of Ireland (Home Rule) Bill

    The third Home Rule bill was introduced into the House of Com-mons by the prime minister on April 11, in a long and able speech in which he outlined clearly the content and effect of its several clauses. A study of the provisions of this important measure naturally suggests comparison with the Gladstonian Home Rule bills of 1886 and

  23. Northern Ireland

    In 1912 the third, and final, Home Rule Bill twice passed the House of Commons, but both times it was defeated in the House of Lords. Protestant Ulster, under the leadership of a prominent barrister and member of Parliament, Edward Carson, Baron Carson of Duncairn, resisted incorporation into a self-governing Ireland.