Creating a Comprehensive Business Plan Rubric
A well-structured business plan is a foundational document for any entrepreneurial venture, serving as a roadmap to guide your business to success. It provides clarity on your business goals, strategies, and financial projections, making it an essential tool for attracting investors and stakeholders. However, evaluating the quality and completeness of a business plan can be challenging, especially when dealing with multiple plans. This is where a business plan rubric comes into play. It’s a systematic and objective way to assess business plans consistently.
How to Create a Comprehensive Business Plan Rubric
1. define your objectives.
Start by identifying the objectives of your business plan rubric. What do you want to assess and measure in the business plans? Your objectives may include evaluating market research, financial projections, marketing strategies, or overall clarity and coherence. Make sure your objectives align with the key components of a well-rounded business plan.
2. Establish Criteria
For each objective, establish specific criteria or factors that you will evaluate. For instance, if you’re assessing market research, your criteria might include the depth of market analysis, competitor research, and target audience insights. Clearly define the criteria for each objective.
3. Assign Weightings
Not all criteria are equally important. Assign weightings to each criterion based on its significance. Weightings reflect the relative importance of different elements in the business plan. For example, financial projections may carry more weight than a company’s historical background.
4. Develop a Scoring System
Create a scoring system for each criterion. You can use a numerical scale (e.g., 1-5, 1-10) or a descriptive scale (e.g., poor, fair, good, excellent). This system allows you to provide a quantitative assessment for each criterion.
5. Provide Clear Descriptions
For each criterion and level on the scoring system, provide clear descriptions of what each level represents. This ensures consistent and objective evaluation. Avoid vague descriptions to prevent subjectivity.
6. Consider the Overall Structure
Include an assessment of the business plan’s overall structure and presentation. Elements to consider might include readability, use of headings, and formatting. A well-organized and visually appealing plan often indicates a more professional and thoughtful approach.
7. Test Your Rubric
Before applying your rubric to assess real business plans, test it with a few sample plans to ensure that it’s clear, fair, and effective. Make any necessary adjustments based on your testing.
8. Evaluate Business Plans
Once your rubric is ready, you can begin evaluating business plans. Review each plan against the criteria, assign scores, and calculate the final scores based on the weightings.
9. Provide Feedback
After assessing the plans, offer constructive feedback to the entrepreneurs or teams behind them. Highlight strengths and weaknesses, and offer recommendations for improvement. This feedback can be invaluable for the plan’s creators.
10. Maintain Consistency
Consistency is key in using a business plan rubric. Ensure that different assessors apply the rubric consistently, and if possible, discuss and calibrate your rubric assessments with other evaluators to maintain fairness and objectivity.
11. Use the Results
The results from your business plan rubric can help you make informed decisions about which plans align best with your investment or support criteria. Plans with higher scores are likely more well-prepared and have thoroughly considered various aspects of their business.
Business Rubric Example
Here are a few examples of criteria that could be included in a business plan rubric along with a corresponding scoring system:
- Identification of target market (5 points)
- Thoroughness of competitor analysis (5 points)
- Assessment of market trends and growth potential (5 points)
- Realistic revenue forecasts (5 points)
- Comprehensive cost analysis (5 points)
- Clear understanding of profit margins (5 points)
- Coherent and effective marketing plan (5 points)
- Utilization of digital marketing tools (5 points)
- Identification of key marketing channels (5 points)
- Description of unique value proposition (5 points)
- Clarity in product development roadmap (5 points)
- Assessment of potential market demand (5 points)
- Demonstrated expertise and experience (5 points)
- Coherence and complementary skills of the team (5 points)
- Clarity in roles and responsibilities (5 points)
- Identification of potential risks (5 points)
- Comprehensive risk mitigation strategies (5 points)
- Contingency plans for identified risks (5 points)
- Clarity and coherence of the business plan structure (5 points)
- Use of appropriate visuals and graphics (5 points)
- Professionalism and readability of the document (5 points)
For each of the criteria listed above, a scoring system can be implemented using a scale such as:
- 1-5 scale (1 being Poor, 5 being Excellent)
- 1-10 scale (1 being Low, 10 being High)
- Descriptive scale (Poor, Fair, Good, Excellent)
In summary, a well-structured business plan rubric is a valuable tool for evaluating and comparing multiple business plans. It provides objectivity, consistency, and fairness in assessing the quality and completeness of these plans, helping you make informed decisions when considering investments or partnerships. This business plan rubric can help assessors evaluate various business plans consistently and objectively, providing a comprehensive overview of the strengths and weaknesses of each plan and aiding in making informed decisions regarding potential investments or collaborations.
- help_outline help
iRubric: Entrepreneurship I rubric
- opportunity recognition, outcome-driven innovation, marketing, strategic planning and action
- My Library Account
- Articles, Books & More
- Course Reserves
- Site Search
- Advanced Search
- Sac State Library
- Research Guides
ENTR 187 - Entrepreneurship
Sample business plans.
- Market Size
- Target Customers & Demographics
- Local Competitors
- Business permits, fees, etc.
- Find Articles
- Citing Sources
- Business Plans Handbook (free) Provides a variety of sample business plans and business plan template.
- Business Plans Handbook (Gale) Great source for sample startup costs and financial plan. Be sure to click the radio button "all volumes" to search all available volumes of Business Plans Handbook. CSUS authentication required. Additional volumes available in print in the library at 2 North Reference HD 62.7 .B865
- Bplans.com Offers sample plans, articles and tools to help you through the process of writing a business plan.
Business Plan Basics
- Business Planning Template Gallery SCORE provides downloadable templates for business planning, finance, sales, marketing, and management.
- How to Write a Business Plan Publishes by Nolo Press, this book provides current business and legal guidance and forms. Available in print at 2 North Reference HD 30.28 .M3839 2005
- Writing a Business Plan This Small Business Administration site includes information on starting or expanding a business. Includes links to example business plans.
Recommended book
- << Previous: Business permits, fees, etc.
- Next: Find Articles >>
- Last Updated: Feb 15, 2024 5:20 PM
- URL: https://csus.libguides.com/entr187
New Business Concepts Pitch Guidelines | Social Ventures Pitch Guidelines | Ten Questions That You Should Try To Answer
New Business Concepts Pitch Guidelines
New Business Concepts will be evaluated on the following judging criteria.
- How well was the concept explained?
- How reasonable, sustainable, and scalable is the new concept?
- Is there a genuine need for the product or service?
- How well was the target market defined?
- What is the size and growth of the market?
- What is the consumers' willingness to pay for the product/service?
- Is the description clear?
- Is the product feasible?
- How easily it can be duplicated?
- Is there a presence of potential substitutes for the product?
- Have the current and potential competitors, competitive response, and analysis of strengths and weaknesses been adequately defined?
- How realistically defined is the marketing plan?
- Does the plan adequately address price, product, place, and promotion?
- Are resources sufficiently allocated for marketing?
- What is the likelihood of securing resources required for production?
- Is there an ability to operate competitively and grow?
- Does the team exhibit the experience and skills required for operation?
- What is the depth and breadth of the team's capabilities?
- Does the team demonstrate the ability to grow with the organization and attract new talent?
- How compelling is the business model?
- Have the resources required for the venture been addressed?
- Has the team clearly and adequately presented a breakeven analysis?
- How reasonable are the financial projections?
- Are there prospects for long-term profitability?
- Did the entrepreneurial team explain funding?
- Were offerings to investors and anticipated returns clearly explained?
- Did the team calculate a realistic valuation?
- How feasible is the exit strategy?
- Did the presenter(s) engage the audience and hold their attention?
- Did the presenter(s) appear to speak with confidence authority?
- Were visual aids (i.e. PowerPoint® slides) clear and valuable?
- Was the pitch exciting and compelling?
- How efficiently did the team allot their time?
Social Venture Pitch Guidelines
Social Ventures will be evaluated on the following judging criteria.
- Does the proposed venture address a significant and critical social problem?
- Does the proposed venture adequately describe the problem it hopes to address and have defined parameters within which it plans to operate?
- Does the entrepreneurial team possess the skills and experience required to translate the plan into action?
- Can they demonstrated the passion, commitment, and perseverance required to overcome inevitable obstacles?
- Is the team comprised of individuals committed to ethical standards?
- Does the proposal approach the social problem in an innovative, exciting, and dynamic way?
- Does the initiative aspire towards clear, realistic and achievable goals, while thinking big?
- Can it be implemented effectively?
- Are there clear and coherent schedules, milestones, objectives, and financial plans?
- Has adequate attention been given to the way in which the product or service is to be produced and/or delivered?
- Do they have, or can likely secure, the resources required for production?
- Will they be able to operate competitively and grow?
- Does the proposed venture include adequate strategies for fundraising and income generation?
- Does it consider the different dimensions of financial and social sustainability in a conscientious manner?
- How will the implementation of this social venture benefit the community and the multiple stakeholders involved?
- Is there the potential for significant social impact and engagement of the broader community?
* While there is some debate regarding the precise definition of a social venture, and what exactly differentiates it from a traditional for profit business, the Selection Committee and Judging Panel will use the following criteria:
- PRIMARY MISSION - is the organization's primary purpose to serve its owners (New Business Concept) or society (Social Venture)
- PRIMARY MEASURE OF SUCCESS - does the organization measure its success primarily by profitability (New Business Concept) or positive social change (Social Venture)
Ten Questions That You Should Try To Answer
Whether pitching a New Business Concept or a Social Venture, try to address the following ten big questions as completely as possible. Remember, you should not simply talk about a general idea (those are "a dime a dozen"), rather, try to present a concise concept with a clear economic model, convincing everyone that you can actually make it happen.
- 1. What's the PROBLEM?
- 2. What's your SOLUTION?
- 3. How large is the MARKET?
- 4. Who is the COMPETITION?
- 5. What makes you so SPECIAL?
- 6. What's your ECONOMIC MODEL?
- 7. How exactly will you achieve SALES?
- 8. Have you assembled a qualified TEAM?
- 9. How will you secure required RESOURCES?
- 10. What are you proposing for an INVESTMENT?
Suggested reading: The Art of the Start by Guy Kawasaki (Penguin 2004), especially Chapter 3, "The Art of Pitching"
Copyright 2016· All rights reserved
Designed by Zymphonies
- Configure block
High School
Independent business plan.
The Independent Business Plan Event involves the development of a comprehensive proposal to start a new business. Any type of business may be used.
Participants
Written entry page limit, appear before a judge, present plan, interview time, sponsored by:.
Essential Elements
Related resources, become a deca insider.
Get the latest news, important notifications, weekly case study and more delivered in your inbox with DECA Direct Weekly.
Become a DECA Insider
Get the latest news, important notifications, weekly case study and more delivered in your inbox.
DECA prepares emerging leaders and entrepreneurs in marketing, finance, hospitality and management in high schools and colleges around the globe.
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
BUSINESS PLAN RUBRIC TEMPLATE PLAN TITLE DATE REVIEWER NAME RUBRIC SCORE SCORING SCALE TOTAL Expectations exceeded 4 EXEMPLARY 25 - 28 Expectations met 3 ACCEPTABLE 21 - 24 Guidelines met 2 NEEDS IMPROVEMENT 16 - 20 Guidelines somewhat met 1 INADEQUATE 0 - 15 Incomplete; Information not available 0 CRITERIA 4 3 2 1 0
Once your rubric is ready, you can begin evaluating business plans. Review each plan against the criteria, assign scores, and calculate the final scores based on the weightings. 9. Provide Feedback. After assessing the plans, offer constructive feedback to the entrepreneurs or teams behind them.
Include: Name of Business, "Business Plan", Name of Students, Date of Submission. 3. History and Background of Your Business Idea A. Name and general location of the business - 1 pt. B. Provide general description of the business - 1 pt. C. Why did you decide to open this particular business? - 1 pts. 3
Students develop a business plan for a business that they are personally interested in starting. Each student will be responsible for all portions of the comprehensive plan that covers everythnig, including Executive Summary, Business Description, writing a mission statement, developing the marketing plan, etc. Rubric Code: H92A96. By ciccatelli.
California State University East Bay MBA Rubrics . Leadership Rubric 10 . Teamwork Rubric 11 . Problem-Solving Rubric 12 . Global Perspective Rubric 13 . Written Communication Rubric 14 . Oral Presentation Rubric 15 . SUNY at New Paltz School of Business . Academic Presentation Skills Rubric 16 . Walton College . Business Plan Rubric 17 ...
Presentation Guideline and Scoring Rubric for Business Plans This competition challenges students to present well-developed business models and implementation plans. On the day of the competition, contestants must bring five printed copies of their presentation slides plus a one to two-page executive summary for review by the judges.
location Rents/ Cost 9. Financial Plan Start- up cost 5 yrs. Prediction financial plan Summary of expenses and income Profit. Highest Score: 10 Lowest Score: 1. 10. SIMULATION OF BUSINESS- Power Point Presentation Actual Video of Business Operation. Highest Score: 45 Lowest Score: 1
Business Plan. Written Business Plan Rubric Student (s): Written Business Plan Rubric Scoring Scale. Each section will be graded if it meets the requirements. It must have full explanations that provide all the necessary details. SCORE. Cover Page. All information present, including: · Business name.
Entrepreneurial Design Project Rubric. Task Description: Create and design a mock storefront business or office for your community from the list below or add a new business that is in the Human Services Pathway. Steps: Select the type of business you may be interested in. Select a name for your business. Design a marketing slogan.
iRubric NX4X642: This course provides the foundational knowledge necessary to develop and enhance participants' entrepreneurial skills. Through the content exploration and the experiential component of the course, they will discover and apply entrepreneurial thinking skills as a strategy to innovate and transform an idea into a business ...
of the business plan fully developed. Idea is realistic, mostly well planned, and 1-2 sections of the business plan are NOT fully developed. Idea is somewhat realistic, partially well planned, and 3-4 sections of the business plan are NOT fully developed. Idea is not realistic, is not well planned, and each part of the business plan is NOT ...
The document outlines an entrepreneurship rubric for written business plans. It lists 11 sections that will be graded on a scale from the highest to lowest points. These sections include a cover page, table of contents, executive summary, business description, product/service description, market analysis, resources, location analysis, financial plan, simulation of business operations, and date ...
suggested tools for writing the business plan, and a rubric for evaluating the plan. Keywords: Business Plan; Entrepreneurship; Executive Summary; Market Analysis; Financial Projections INTRODUCTION ntrepreneurship education is defined as "the conveyance of entrepreneurial knowledge to students in
To fill this gap, this paper explores rubric-based assessment of entrepreneurial minded learning (EML) by examining (1) the underlying pedagogical approaches, models, and theories that contextualize rubrics-based assessment, (2) elements of rubrics relevant to the assessment of EM-related learning outcomes, (3) the benefits and challenges of ...
Written plan supports assertions in the oral presentation. Written plan communicates business concept as a stand-alone document, and stimulates potential investor attention. Quality of Visual Aids (10 Points) Number of points: ____ Clear, interesting visual aids that help explain the business ideas and concepts. May bring sample products,
Role rubrics are best structured as analytic rubrics where the rows identify the different aspects of the role and the columns are the seniority levels (e.g. Junior Engineer, Engineer, Senior Engineer, Principle Engineer, etc). These rubrics can then be used for employee performance assessments, promotions, transfers and external hiring.
Great source for sample startup costs and financial plan. Be sure to click the radio button "all volumes" to search all available volumes of Business Plans Handbook. CSUS authentication required. Additional volumes available in print in the library at 2 North Reference HD 62.7 .B865
Had each part of the marketing plan and started to support some of the decisions but still left for some questions. Had each part of the marketing plan and supported the decisions. Clearly presented. Finance & Accounting - Show an accounting plan for the business, outlining the fixed and variable costs as well as project ted revenue.
5. Feasibility: A demonstration that the venture can be successfully implemented. Does the initiative aspire towards clear, realistic and achievable goals, while thinking big? Can it be implemented effectively? 6. Planning: A clear and well-defined strategy to achieve objectives and goals.
Grading Rubric for Social Enterprise Business Plans Category Scoring Criteria Grade Core Content (60%) The plan clearly identifies a need, problem or opportunity that can be addressed through social entrepreneurship and presents an innovative or unique solution or a set of solutions that have transformative potential.
The Independent Business Plan Event involves the development of a comprehensive proposal to start a new business. Any type of business may be used. ... Sample Exam. Sample Event. District Level Instructional Areas. Competition Advice. Related Resources. ... DECA prepares emerging leaders and entrepreneurs in marketing, finance, hospitality and ...
Sample Business Plan mindanao state university iligan institute of technology college of business administration and accountancy department of marketing alibata. ... Entrepreneurship (Entrep 100) 8 Documents. Students shared 8 documents in this course. ... Rubrics-FOR- Reporting; Frequency Distribution; Story - ASDAS;
This product makes grading easy with the included grading rubric for assessing student wo. Subjects: Business, Career and Technical Education. Grades: 9 th - 12 th. Types: Projects, Activities, Rubrics. Also included in: Abridged Food Truck Business, Marketing, and Finance Semester Project Bundle. $3.99.