Main navigation
- Graduate Students
- Faculty & Staff
- General requirements
- Preparation of a thesis
- Initial Thesis Submission
- Thesis examiners
- Evaluation of written thesis
- Thesis examination failures
- Doctoral oral defence
- Final Thesis Submission
- Thesis Writing and Support Resources
- Letters of Completion/PGWP
Evaluation of a Written Thesis
Examiners are asked to evaluate the thesis in myThesis, according to the criteria in the respective thesis examiner report for a Master's or Doctoral thesis. For an example of the criteria, please see the forms: see: Master's Examiner report form ; Doctoral Examiner report form (note these forms are now integrated in myThesis).
Examiners provide an overall judgment of 'passed' or ‘not passed’, in addition to a written report. For Master's students, this evaluation determines whether or not the thesis is ready for final submission, even if minor changes are recommended. For Doctoral candidates, this evaluation determines whether or not the candidate is ready to proceed to the oral defence.
If the thesis meets the general criteria for the degree sought, as well as those listed on the examiner's report form it should be evaluated as 'Passed', even if some changes are recommended.
If the overall judgement is 'Passed', examiners are asked to provide:
- A report that includes any recommendations for minor revisions to the thesis (i.e., stylistic or editorial changes that can be completed in three weeks or less).
- For doctoral theses, External Examiners who will not be at the oral defence must also provide a list of questions to be asked of the candidate at the oral defence.
An evaluation of 'Not Passed' should be given if:
- the need for a new study, experimentation, or significant additional research or reformulation.
- the need to address major problems with the presentation of the work. Stylistic or editorial changes are not normally considered to be major revisions, but if the quality of the presentation is so poor that extensive rewriting is required, the thesis should not be passed.
- At least one of the Criteria for the Evaluation of the Thesis (see Master's Examiner report form ; Doctoral Examiner report form ) is judged as unsatisfactory.
Examiners are asked to identify required changes clearly in their reports. The supervisor or another designated person will ensure that the student corrects the thesis and that it appropriately reflects the examiners' suggestions for revisions prior to re-submission of the thesis.
The candidate will normally revise and re-submit the thesis for re-assessment, usually by the same examiner. If/when review of the revised thesis is required, the Thesis Unit will contact the initial examiner to determine their availability. In rare cases, a revised thesis may be sent to a new examiner if the first examiner is not available to re-examine the thesis. For more, please see Thesis examination failures.
If the revised thesis is again ‘not passed’, the student will be withdrawn from the University unless the decision is reversed through an appeal to the Hearing Committee (Bias, Error, or Misrepresentation ).
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial 4.0 International License . Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies, McGill University .
Department and University Information
Graduate and postdoctoral studies.
Research guidance, Research Journals, Top Universities
PhD thesis evaluation report sample | Download external examiner report sample
In this blog post, you will be able to download the PhD thesis evaluation report sample.
PhD thesis evaluation report sample
ZZZZ UNIVERSITY, HIMACHAL PRADESH.
Summary of Examiners Report
A summary in this format should accompany the examiner’s full report to the Research Committee. Criteria to be used as the basis of recommendations and advice on the format of your report are provided in separate guidelines. Written reports are required to be 1-2 pages in length. Reasons for recommendation 4 and 5 should stand scrutiny in an appeal process.
Name of Candidate:
Title of Thesis:
Recommendation:
Commendation:
If you believe it is merited, please tick one box only:
The candidate’s thesis will be considered as an example of outstanding work when either box is checked.
Place: Signature of the Examiner
Format of PhD Thesis
Share this:
Leave a comment cancel reply.
Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.
Notify me of follow-up comments by email.
Notify me of new posts by email.
Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.
To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser .
Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link.
- We're Hiring!
- Help Center
DETAILED Ph D REPORT
Related Papers
nqobile buthelezi
Mamta Mohapatra
David Ravid
Sathish kumar
International Journal for Research in Applied Science & Engineering Technology (IJRASET)
IJRASET Publication
All industrial civilizations share the fundamental trait of widespread wage employment. Workers/employees and employers/management are two separate categories of people who are looking for wage employment, respectively. Known variously as labour-management relations, labour relations, industrial relations, or employer-employee relations, these two groups' relationships are structured. With the exception of the first, these definitions indicate that the relations are at minimum inclusive on the part of the employees. In regards to all problems that concern its members, the labour union negotiates with employers and management. Consequently, the two groups' relationships are structured.
wftucentral.org
Femi Aborisade
jose vattakuzhy
Of late, ‘Draft Labour Code on Industrial Relation Bill 2015’ received from Ministry of Labour to be placed before monsoon session of the parliament, after tripartite discussions with stake holders and approval from the cabinet. For creating a new industrial relation’s law the proposed Code on industrial relation is one of the initiatives of the government to subsume 44 labour laws into five broad codes, dealing with industrial relation, wages, social security, industrial safety and welfare. Simultaneously recent developments in the labour movements across the country , like strikes of workers which occurs without support of political based unions, the participation of large number of workers, including unorganised workers in the last national wide strike on 2nd September and the transformation of labour landscape in India due to the globlisation , all these factors along with Government’s moves are seem to be indicators for the backdrop to intensify the deliberations on labour activism in India.
Journal of Industrial Relations
Howard Guille
RELATED PAPERS
Astri Widiastuti
Synergismus Scyentifica Utfpr
ELISETE GUIMARAES
Experimental Hematology
Louis Pelus
Shobha Menon
Études Ricoeuriennes / Ricoeur Studies
Roger Savage
Morten Nørholm
Centro de Publicaciones Universidad Nacional del Litoral
Viviana Suarez
Continuum Mechanics and Thermodynamics
giuseppe Puglisi
Martín Garrido
Rene Boonen
Instituut voor Natuur- en Bosonderzoek
Robin Guelinckx
SSRN Electronic Journal
Soil Rens Jurnal Ilmiah Lingkungan Tanah Pertanian
vira kusuma dewi
Solid State Communications
Krishna Garg
Naeem Habib
Molecular Psychiatry
Bruce Gudmundsson
Journal of Cleaner Production
Faris Salman
Siniša Srečec
Environmental Science and Pollution Research
Gabriela Woźniak
Physical Review B
Donato Greco
REPRESENTAMEN
edy sudaryanto
Journal of Project Management
Javier Pajares
（本科/硕士毕业证书、成绩单） 大学Offer录取通知书、
Research Square (Research Square)
Thomas A Garran
- We're Hiring!
- Help Center
- Find new research papers in:
- Health Sciences
- Earth Sciences
- Cognitive Science
- Mathematics
- Computer Science
- Academia ©2024
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
Examiner Report - Doctoral Thesis . Report Due Date: Name of Student: Degree/Unit: Thesis Title: As a thesis examiner, you will complete this form and attach a written report providing a detailed justification of your evaluation. The deadline to send this form and your written report to Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies (email:
the PhD thesis and determines often the success or failure of the whole PhD project. In the introductory part of this evaluation, I commended author´s choice of the topic. Unfortunately, I consider the definition of the goals and the scope of the thesis rather vague. I admit that the scope
Template for PhD evaluation reports To facilitate the composition of a synthetic evaluation report, PhD committee members are asked to follow the present template when preparing their individual reports. Specific comments (that would be more like suggestions for rewriting rather than elements of an evaluation) can be added separately. The final ...
Evaluation of a Written Thesis. Examiners are asked to evaluate the thesis in myThesis, according to the criteria in the respective thesis examiner report for a Master's or Doctoral thesis. For an example of the criteria, please see the forms: see: Master's Examiner report form; Doctoral Examiner report form (note these forms are now integrated ...
Often, you can't answer all the research question (s) even with a PhD and so you need to write what you could not do in the final part of the thesis as suggestions for further research. Otherwise an examiner may bring up the gaps and absences as negatives in their assessment of the thesis. You need to have thought about this and noted these gaps.
The Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) is a research degree which comprises a thesis to the value of 360 credits. ... riteria for evaluation of the thesis to be used as the basis for the written report ... Both the Thesis Assessment Report (in Word format) and Recommendation form should be emailed to [email protected]. Thank you. DRC . 4. Author:
On the next three pages are the titles and introductions to two first year reports. Skim them to identify which of the elements in the Introduction model on page 9 are present in each one. Label the main parts B (Background to the Research), RES (the Research), and REP (the Report).
The format of the thesis is not at stake in the evaluation report. Doctoral students undergo doctoral training and their grades from Doctoral school count 1/4 of the final grade. Doctoral school grades evaluate the Doctoral student's scientific performance beyond the thesis. Your evaluation report therefore is meant to focus on the written ...
Evaluation Report of PhD Thesis ... I Acceptable The Thesis is acceptable in the present form for the award of the Ph.D Degree II Acceptable after Minor Technical Revisions/Language Corrections The thesis is acceptable after minor revisions as specified to the satisfaction of the Oral Board during viva-voce examination.
thesis, and consists of four parts, namely: I. OVERVIEW OF THE DISSERTATION Here, briefly describe the content of the doctoral thesis in the same form as that of the Summary submitted to the Faculty Council of the Medical Faculty of the University of Zagreb (number of pages, number of photos and tables, number of references and chapters and the ...
Your anonymized thesis evaluation report will only be disclosed to fellow committee members when the PhD t hesis is considered for a cum laude. The (co-)promotor(s) will receive your anonymised thesis evaluation report: - in case the thesis is graded as 'unacceptable', to allow the candidate to improve the thesis.
Evaluation Report of Ph.D. Thesis 1. Name of Student: 2. Roll No.: 3. Department: 4. General Features of Thesis ... writing and which is communicated to the oral board together with my report. ... The thesis is acceptable in the present form for the award of the Ph.D. degree. (ii) The thesis is acceptable and the corrections, modifications, and ...
study presented in Chapter 2a. As such, I wrote a brief report to limit unnecessary repetition, given the current format of the thesis whereby the study in Chapter 2b directly follows that of Chapter 2a. When the results of this study are written up as a paper to be submitted for publication, I will extend
The thesis in its present form is commended for the award of the Ph.D. degree. 2. The thesis is commended for the award of the Ph.D. degree. ... Title of the thesis: Detailed Report Date: Signature: Name and address of the examiner . Title: Ref : Acad/PhD/2007/02612203 Author: cc Created Date: 11/27/2020 11:50:06 AM ...
A sample copy of the form for forming the panel of examiners for evaluation of Ph.D. thesis is placed at Annexure-I. 3.Thesis submission Within 30 days of submission of synopsis the students submits soft copy (pdf) of the thesis for evaluation. A student can be asked to submit the hard copy of the thesis if required by the examiner. The format ...
PhD thesis evaluation report sample. ZZZZ UNIVERSITY, HIMACHAL PRADESH. Summary of Examiners Report. A summary in this format should accompany the examiner's full report to the Research Committee. Criteria to be used as the basis of recommendations and advice on the format of your report are provided in separate guidelines.
After including all the comments/suggestions, the thesis proposal report and the seminar evaluation form should be submitted to the academic office. Thesis proposal report is essential as it formally outlines your intended research. This means you need to provide details on how you will go about your research during PhD program, including:
The dissertation contains an introduction, three chapters, conclusion, bibliography and 4 appendices. The distribution of text in the three chapters is disproportionate (100/28/22 pp). The methods used in the thesis are in general adequate and justified. Taking the thesis as a whole, the author demonstrates sufficiently the ability to choose
PhD Thesis Evaluation Report By Prof. Milena Staneva Staneva, MD, PhD Head of Angiology Clinic, Acibadem City Clinic MHAT Tokuda EAD of the dissertation for obtaining the educational and scientific degree "Doctor" in the field of higher education 7. Health and sport, professional field 7.1. Medicine, Doctoral Program in Internal Medicine.
Your technical report reached 6,000 reads Achieved on October 1, 2020 Technical report: A Sample; M. Sc. Thesis Evaluation Report . View full-text. Data. Full-text available.
thesis, and also notices its limitations, showing clearly that the PhD student has a comprehensive understanding of the context of her work. Maybe an overview of all the investigated catalysts in a table or in a graphical representation would be a good idea here. Final evaluation statement This thesis represents a great deal of work.
Ph. D. Theses Evaluation RePort 1. Name of Candidate: 2. Name of Degree and Subject: 3. Title of Thesis: 4. Full Name & Address of Examiner: Manisha Bhimrao Patil Ph.D. in Computer Science "Modeling Decision Support System based on Predicted land use Pattern: A Case Study of Pune Metropolis" Prof. B.V. Pawar, Professor & Director, School of Computer Science N orth M aharashtra Univers itY,
I commend the thesis for the award of Ph.D. degree of the Madras University for the following reasons: 1. The theme of the thesis is a rarely researched one in Indian Sociology and hence it is an innovative effort. 2. The formulation of the problem is clear and the execution of the study is neat.