mesne assignments meaning

Simple English definitions for legal terms

mesne assignment

Read a random definition: incorporated

A quick definition of mesne assignment:

A more thorough explanation:.

A mesne assignment is an intermediate assignment, meaning any assignment before the final one. It is a legal term used to describe the transfer of rights or property from one person to another.

For example, if John assigns his property to Jane, and Jane assigns the same property to Tom, then Jane's assignment to Tom is a mesne assignment because it is an intermediate assignment between John's original assignment and the final assignment to Tom.

Another example of a mesne assignment is when a debtor assigns their property to a trustee, who then assigns it to a creditor. The trustee's assignment is a mesne assignment because it is an intermediate assignment between the debtor's original assignment and the final assignment to the creditor.

Overall, a mesne assignment is any assignment that occurs between the original assignment and the final assignment of a property or right.

mesne agreement | mesne conveyance

• Data download

Help us make LSD better!

• To save this word, you'll need to log in. Log In

Definition of mesne

Word history.

Anglo-French mesne, meiene — more at mean

circa 1558, in the meaning defined above

Phrases Containing mesne

Dictionary entries near mesne, cite this entry.

“Mesne.” Merriam-Webster.com Dictionary , Merriam-Webster, https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/mesne. Accessed 26 Apr. 2024.

Subscribe to America's largest dictionary and get thousands more definitions and advanced search—ad free!

Can you solve 4 words at once?

Word of the day.

See Definitions and Examples »

Get Word of the Day daily email!

Popular in Grammar & Usage

More commonly misspelled words, commonly misspelled words, how to use em dashes (—), en dashes (–) , and hyphens (-), absent letters that are heard anyway, how to use accents and diacritical marks, popular in wordplay, 9 superb owl words, 'gaslighting,' 'woke,' 'democracy,' and other top lookups, 10 words for lesser-known games and sports, your favorite band is in the dictionary, etymologies for every day of the week, games & quizzes.

• Daily Crossword
• Word Puzzle
• Word Finder
• Word of the Day
• Synonym of the Day
• Word of the Year
• Language stories
• All featured
• Gender and sexuality
• All pop culture
• Grammar Coach ™
• Writing hub
• Grammar essentials
• Commonly confused
• All writing tips
• Pop culture
• Writing tips

Advertisement

• intermediate or intervening.

a mesne assignment

• mesne profits rents or profits accruing during the rightful owner's exclusion from his land

Discover More

Word history and origins.

Origin of mesne 1

Example Sentences

An important alteration in the law took place this session, in the abolition of imprisonment for debt on mesne process.

Having effected this object it seemed but right to abolish imprisonment on mesne process.

Resigned to accept position of Register of Mesne Conveyances, a very important office which he held for several years.

Vavassors, that is, mesne tenants, are particularly mentioned in one enumeration of barons attending the court.

The point of particular reform aimed at by the Bill was to abolish what was called arrest on mesne process.

• TheFreeDictionary
• Word / Article
• Starts with
• Free toolbar & extensions
• Word of the Day
• Free content

Intermediate; intervening; the middle between two extremes, especially of rank or time. In feudal law, an intermediate lord; a lord who stood between a tenant and the chief lord; a lord who was also a tenant.

Cross-references

Feudalism .

(mean, with a silent s) adj. from Norman French for intermediate, the middle point between two extremes. It is seldom used, except in reference to "mesne profits." (See: mesne profits )

MESNE. The middle between two extremes, that part between the commencement and the end, as it relates to time.      2. Hence the profits which a man receives between disseisin and recovery of lands are called mesne profits. (q.v.) Process which is issued in a suit between the original and final process, is called mesne process. (q.v.)      3. In England, the word mesne also applies to a dignity: those persons who hold lordships or manors of some superior who is called lord paramount, and grant the same to inferior persons, are called mesne lords.

MESNE, WRIT of. The name of an ancient writ, which lies when: the lord paramount distrains on the tenant paravail; the latter shall have a writ of mesne against the lord who is mesne. F. N. B. 316.

PROCESS, MESNE, practice. By this term is generally understood any writ issued in the course of a suit between the original process and execution.      2. By this term is also meant the writ or proceedings in an action to summon or bring the defendant into court, or compel him to appear or put in bail, and then to hear and answer the plaintiffs claim. 3 Chit. Pr. 140.

• Arrest in civil cases
• Continuing Trespass
• Courts of the united states
• Mesne process
• mesne profits
• Prisoner one held in confinement against his will
• sequestration
• mercantile agent
• mercantile law
• Merchandise
• Merchant demand for failure to pay
• Merchantable
• merchantable quality
• Merchantman
• Merchants' accounts
• Mercian Law
• Mercis appellatio ad res mobiles tantum pertinet
• Meredith, James Howard
• Merger Treaty
• Mergers and Acquisitions
• Merit System
• Merit Systems Protection Board
• Merx est quidquid vendi potest
• Metes and Bounds
• Metre or meter
• Meubles meublans
• Mexico and the United States
• Mibilia personam sequuntur
• Micel gemot
• Michaelmas term
• Michigan v. Tucker
• microcap stock
• Middleman contracts
• Midnight Judges
• Migratory Bird Treaty of 1918
• Military Government
• Mesmerize (disambiguation)
• mesmerizedly
• mesmerizers
• mesmerizing
• mesmerizingly
• mesmeromania
• Mesna, Adriamycin, and Ifosfamide
• mesne lords
• Mesne profits
• Meso America
• meso compounds
• Meso-America
• Meso-American
• Meso-appendix
• meso-cystine
• Meso-Diaminopimelic Acid
• meso-inositol
• meso-ionic compound
• Mesoamerica
• Mesoamérica
• Mesoamerican
• Mesoamerican architecture
• Mesoamerican Astrology
• Mesoamerican Barrier Reef System
• Mesoamerican Centre for Theoretical Physics
• Facebook Share

Legal Dictionary

Mesne Assignment

Concept of mesne assignment in the context of real property.

A short definition of Mesne Assignment: Assignment from A to B to C to D would be described as passing from A by “mesne assignments” to D.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

The Law Dictionary

TheLaw.com Law Dictionary & Black's Law Dictionary 2nd Ed.

Intermediate; intervening; the middle between two extremes, especially of rank or time. An intermediate lor,d; a lord who. stood between a tenant and the chief lord; a lord who was also a tenant “Lord, mesne, and tenant; the tenant hojdeth by four pence, and the mesne by twelve pence.” Co. Litt. 23a. Mesne assignment. If A. grant a lease of land to B., andB. assign his interest to C, and” . in his turn assign his interest therein to D., in this case the assignments so made by B. and C would be termed “mesne assignments;” that is, they would be assignments intervening between A.’s original grant and the vesting of D. ‘8 interest in the land under the last assignment Brown. Mesne incumbrance. An intermediate charge, burden, or liability; an incumbrance which has been created or has attached to property between two given periods. Mesne lord. In old English law. A middle or intermediate lord; a lord who held of a superior lord. 2 Bl. Comm. 59. More commonly termed a “mesne,” (q. v.) Mesne, writ of. An ancient and abolished writ, which was when the lord paramount distrained on the tenant paravail. The latter had a writ of mesne against the mesne lord.” As to mesne “Conveyance,” “Process,” and “Profits,” see those titles.

No related posts found

• Legal Terms
• Editorial Guidelines
• © 1995 – 2016 TheLaw.com LLC

mesne profits

Primary tabs.

Mesne (reads as “mean”) profits is the damages for trespass. The term “mesne profits” means “intermediate profits.” (See Cracchiolo v. State, 146 Ariz. 452(Appeals Court, Division 2,1985) for more detail.) If a trespasser has created any damage to the landowner, such as lower the value of the land, or has taken the land’s occupation value, the trespasser would have to compensate the landowner.

Mesne profits often result from the trespasser’s removal of products of the land, such as minerals, timber, etc. They can also be resulted from a hold-over case, in which case the landlord can be recovered for rental value.

[Last updated in August of 2020 by the Wex Definitions Team ]

• landlord & tenant
• property & real estate law
• wex definitions

Register to get FREE access

• M and M lien
• Maara shell
• Macadam road
• Macadamization
• Macaranga gum
• Macassar oil
• Mace-bearer
• Mace-griefs
• Macedo, macedonis
• Macedonia, macedoniae
• Macedonian Decree
• Macedonianism
• Macedonicus, macedonica, macedonicum
• Macedonienis, macedonienis, macedoniene
• Macedonius, macedonia, macedonium
• Macellarius
• Macellum, macelli
• Macer, macra -um, macrior -or -us, macerrimus -a -um
• Maceria, maceriae
• Maceries, maceriei
• Macero, macerare, maceravi, maceratus
• Macesco, macescere
• Machaera, machaerae
• Machiavelian
• Machiavelism
• Machicolated
• Machicolation
• Machicoulis
• Machina, machinae
• Machinamentum, machinamenti
• Machinans absque probabili causa
• Machinatio, machinationis
• Machination
• Machinator, machinatoris
• Machine gun
• Machinor, machinari, machinatus sum
• Machærodus, Machairodus
• Macies, maciei
• Macilentus, macilenta -um, macilentior -or -us, macilentissimus -a -um
• Mackinaw blanket
• Macrame lace
• Macrencephalic
• Macresco, macrescere
• Macro-chemistry
• Macrobiotic
• Macrobiotics
• Macrocephalous
• Macrochires
• Macrocollum, macrocolli
• Macrocosmic
• Macrocosmus, macrocosmi
• Macrocystis
• Macrodactyl
• Macrodactylic
• Macrodiagonal
• Macroglossia
• Macrognathic
• Macrologus, macrologi
• Macronosia, macronosiae
• Macronozia, macronoziae
• Macropetalous
• Macrophyllous
• Macropinacoid
• Macropodian
• Macropodous
• Macropteres
• Macropterous
• Macropyramid
• Macroscopic
• Macrosporangium
• Macrosporic
• Macrozoospore
• Mactator, mactatoris
• Macto, mactare, mactavi, mactatus
• Mactus, macta, mactum
• Macula, maculae

An assignment from X to Y, then from Y to Z, then from Z to A would be described as passing from X by mesne assignments to A. Any assignment before the last one.

• Privacy Policy
• Legal Statements
• Terms and Conditions

© 2024 Casebriefsco.com. All Rights Reserved.

• Find a Lawyer
• Ask a Lawyer
• Research the Law
• Law Schools
• Laws & Regs
• Newsletters
• Justia Connect
• Pro Membership
• Basic Membership
• Justia Lawyer Directory
• Platinum Placements
• Gold Placements
• Justia Elevate
• Justia Amplify
• PPC Management
• Google Business Profile
• Social Media
• Justia Onward Blog
• A middle point or intermediate stage between two extremes, usually applied to profits
• The landowner sued for mesne profits after the wrongful occupation of his property.
• The dispute involved the tenants and their claim to mesne profits.
• The court awarded the landlord mesne profits from the illegal occupation.
• Bankruptcy Lawyers
• Business Lawyers
• Criminal Lawyers
• Employment Lawyers
• Estate Planning Lawyers
• Family Lawyers
• Personal Injury Lawyers
• Estate Planning
• Personal Injury
• Business Formation
• Business Operations
• Intellectual Property
• International Trade
• Real Estate
• Financial Aid
• Course Outlines
• Law Journals
• US Constitution
• Regulations
• Supreme Court
• Circuit Courts
• District Courts
• Dockets & Filings
• State Constitutions
• State Codes
• State Case Law
• Legal Blogs
• Business Forms
• Product Recalls
• Justia Connect Membership
• Justia Premium Placements
• Justia Elevate (SEO, Websites)
• Justia Amplify (PPC, GBP)
• Testimonials

Definition of 'mesne'

Mesne in american english, mesne in british english.

Trends of mesne

View usage over: Since Exist Last 10 years Last 50 years Last 100 years Last 300 years

Browse alphabetically mesne

• mesmerizing
• mesne profits
• All ENGLISH words that begin with 'M'

Related terms of mesne

Quick word challenge

Quiz Review

Score: 0 / 5

Wordle Helper

Scrabble Tools

Related Content

• practice notes (19)
• precedents (3)
• q&as (20)

Mesne profits definition

What does mesne profits mean, view the related practice notes about mesne profits, property case tracker—2023 [archived].

Property case tracker—2023 [Archived] The Property case tracker is a list of key judgments from 2023 which we consider relevant...

VAT issues for lease assignments and terminations

VAT issues for lease assignments and terminations This Practice Note is about the VAT issues to consider on the assignment...

Discover our 19 Practice Notes on Mesne profits

View the related precedents about Mesne profits

Particulars of claim for forfeiture for breach (other than rent arrears).

Particulars of claim for forfeiture for breach (other than rent arrears) 1 The Claimant is the [freehold...

Particulars of claim for forfeiture for rent arrears

Particulars of claim for forfeiture for rent arrears Particulars of Claim 1 The Claimant is the [freehold...

Dive into our 3 Precedents related to Mesne profits

View the related q&as about Mesne profits

Where a possession order has been granted and the tenants have remained in the property past the possession date, when the tenants provide non earmarked sums equal to the standard ‘rent’ payments, can the landlord accept these sums or should this be returned to the tenants furthermore, can the landlord choose to attribute these funds to the costs sums ordered and existing rental arrears.

Where a possession order has been granted and the tenants have remained in the property past the possession date, when...

Are there any specific cases where a tenant holding over after the termination of a tenancy was held to be pursuant to a periodic tenancy or a tenancy at will?

Are there any specific cases where a tenant holding over after the termination of a tenancy was held to...

See the 20 Q&As about Mesne profits

View the related News about Mesne profits

Property weekly highlights—26 january 2023.

This week's edition of Property weekly highlights includes: a reminder that the transitional period in the Economic Crime (Transparency and...

PI & Clinical Negligence weekly highlights—23 June 2022

This week’s edition of PI & Clinical Negligence weekly highlights includes a news analysis on a gas explosion and the...

Read the latest 27 News articles on Mesne profits

Speed up all aspects of your legal work with tools that help you to work faster and smarter. Win cases, close deals and grow your business–all whilst saving time and reducing risk.

Access this content for free with a 7 day trial of LexisNexis and benefit from:

• Instant clarification on points of law
• Smart search
• Workflow tools
• 41 practice areas

** Trials are provided to all LexisNexis content, excluding Practice Compliance, Practice Management and Risk and Compliance, subscription packages are tailored to your specific needs. To discuss trialling these LexisNexis services please email customer service via our online form. Free trials are only available to individuals based in the UK, Ireland and selected UK overseas territories and Caribbean countries. We may terminate this trial at any time or decide not to give a trial, for any reason. Trial includes one question to LexisAsk during the length of the trial.

"The forms and precedents section is essential so that I can quickly and easily look up provisions to include in templates or bespoke project contracts."

Access all documents on Mesne profits

0330 161 1234

• International Sales(Includes Middle East)
• Latin America and the Caribbean
• Netherlands
• New Zealand
• Philippines
• South Africa
• Switzerland
• United States

Popular Links

• Supplier Payment Terms
• Partner Alliance Programme

HELP & SUPPORT

• Legal Help and Support
• Tolley Tax Help and Support

LEGAL SOLUTIONS

• Compliance and Risk
• Forms and Documents
• Legal Drafting
• Legal Research
• Magazines and Journals
• News and Media Analysis
• Practice Management
• Privacy Policy
• Cookie Settings
• Terms & Conditions
• Data Protection Inquiry
• Protecting Human Rights: Our Modern Slavery Agreement

• TheFreeDictionary
• Word / Article
• Starts with
• Free toolbar & extensions
• Word of the Day
• Free content
• Mesne process
• Mesial plane
• mesityl oxide
• Mesitylenate
• Mesmer Franz
• mesmerization
• mesmerizing
• mesmeromania
• Mesoamerica
• Mesoamerican
• Mesoamericanist
• mesobenthos
• mesoblastic
• Mesobranchial
• Mesobronchium
• mesocephalic
• Mesocephalon
• Mesocephalous
• Mesocoracoid
• Mesocricetus
• Mesmerize (disambiguation)
• mesmerizedly
• mesmerizers
• mesmerizingly
• Mesna, Adriamycin, and Ifosfamide
• mesne lords
• Mesne profits
• Meso America
• meso compounds
• Meso-America
• Meso-American
• Meso-appendix
• meso-cystine
• Meso-Diaminopimelic Acid
• meso-inositol
• meso-ionic compound
• Mesoamérica
• Mesoamerican architecture
• Mesoamerican Astrology
• Mesoamerican Barrier Reef System
• Mesoamerican Centre for Theoretical Physics
• Facebook Share

Words and phrases

Personal account.

• Access or purchase personal subscriptions
• Get our newsletter
• Save searches
• Set display preferences

Institutional access

Sign in with library card

Sign in with username / password

Recommend to your librarian

Institutional account management

Sign in as administrator on Oxford Academic

mesne process noun

• Hide all quotations

What does the noun mesne process mean?

There is one meaning in OED's entry for the noun mesne process . See ‘Meaning & use’ for definition, usage, and quotation evidence.

How common is the noun mesne process ?

Where does the noun mesne process come from.

Earliest known use

early 1600s

The earliest known use of the noun mesne process is in the early 1600s.

OED's earliest evidence for mesne process is from before 1625, in the writing of Henry Finch, author and lawyer.

mesne process is formed within English, by compounding.

Etymons: mesne adj. , process n.

Nearby entries

• mesnage, n. 1667
• mesnage, v. 1654–95
• mesnagery, n. 1653–93
• mesnagier, n. 1693
• mesnality, n. 1643–1848
• mesnalty, n. 1542–1768
• mesne, adv., adj., & n. 1439–
• mesne encumbrance, n. 1812–
• mesne land, n. a1575
• mesne lord, n. 1611–
• mesne process, n. a1625–
• mesne profits, n. a1558–
• mesne tenant, n. 1853–
• meso, adj. 1896–
• meso-, comb. form
• Mesoamerica, n. 1948–
• Mesoamerican, adj. & n. 1948–
• Mesoamericanist, n. 1948–
• mesoaortitis, n. 1909–
• meso-appendix, n. 1837–
• mesoarial, adj. 1875

Thank you for visiting Oxford English Dictionary

To continue reading, please sign in below or purchase a subscription. After purchasing, please sign in below to access the content.

Meaning & use

Entry history for mesne process, n..

Originally published as part of the entry for mesne, adv., adj., & n.

mesne, adv., adj., & n. was revised in September 2001.

oed.com is a living text, updated every three months. Modifications may include:

• further revisions to definitions, pronunciation, etymology, headwords, variant spellings, quotations, and dates;
• new senses, phrases, and quotations.

Earlier versions of this entry were published in:

OED First Edition (1906)

• Find out more

OED Second Edition (1989)

• View mesne, a., n., and adv. in OED Second Edition

Please submit your feedback for mesne process, n.

Please include your email address if you are happy to be contacted about your feedback. OUP will not use this email address for any other purpose.

Citation details

Factsheet for mesne process, n., browse entry.

The Law Dictionary

Your Free Online Legal Dictionary • Featuring Black’s Law Dictionary, 2nd Ed.

MEAN, or MESNE Definition & Legal Meaning

Definition & citations:.

A middle between two extremes, whether applied to persons, things, or time.

This article contains general legal information but does not constitute professional legal advice for your particular situation. The Law Dictionary is not a law firm, and this page does not create an attorney-client or legal adviser relationship. If you have specific questions, please consult a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction.

Browse Legal Articles

Business Formation

Business Law

Child Custody & Support

Criminal Law

Employment & Labor Law

Estate Planning

Immigration

Intellectual Property

Landlord-Tenant

Motor Vehicle Accidents

Personal Injury

Real Estate & Property Law

Traffic Violations

Browse by Area of Law

Powered by Black’s Law Dictionary, Free 2nd ed., and The Law Dictionary .

About The Law Dictionary

Terms and Conditions

Privacy Policy

Mesne Profits

• Post author By Hemant More
• Post date October 9, 2020
• 2 Comments on Mesne Profits

Indian Legal System > Civil Laws > The Code of Civil Procedure > Mesne Profits

The right to possession is a sacred right guaranteed to all law-abiding citizens. If the rightful owner is deprived of his possession and at the same time he is deprived of the income he can obtain from such possession, then he should be compensated with damages. In such situation the concept of mesne profits comes into play. Mesne profits are profits to which a person is entitled but from, which he has been kept out by the defendant. Simply ‘Mesne Profits” means rents or profits accruing during the rightful owner’s exclusion from his land and interest accrued on the profit. A claim for mesne profits is usually joined with the action for recovery of the possession of the land. Relevant provision of law concerned with mesne profits are

• Section 2(12) of C.P.C.
• Order 2, Rule 4 and order 20 Rule 12 of C.P.C.

Concept of Ownership:

The concept of ownership is one of the fundamental juristic concepts common to all system of law. Ownership is a relation of a person to an object which is exclusive or absolute and ultimate. The person who stands in this relation is called the ‘owner’ and he has a right of complete control and enjoyment of the object. Ownership consists of an innumerable number of claims, liberties, powers & immunities with regard to the things owned.

According to Austin, “ownership means a right which avails against everyone who is subject to the law conferring right to put thing to user of infinite nature”.

According to Hibbert ownership includes four kinds of rights within itself.

• Right to use a thing;
• Right to exclude others from using the thing;
• Disposing of the thing;
• Right to destroy it.

In Blacks Law Dictionary, ownership has been defined as “collection of rights of rights to use & enjoy property, including the right to transmit it to others”.

Concept of Mesne Profits:

According to Section 2(12) of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908, “mesne profits” of property means those profits which the person in wrongful possession of such property actually received or might with ordinary diligence have received there from, together with interest on such profits, but shall not include profits due to improvements made by the person in wrongful possession.

It is to be noted that this definition explicitly excludes any profit earned due to improvement in the property made by the person in unlawful possession of such property.

Illustration 1:

A is in wrongful possession of B’s house. B has rented some part of this house to some subtenants. Thus depriving A, B is receiving profits from such property. Such profits are known as ‘Mesne Profits’. Hence A has right to claim for the profits which have been received by B from the unlawful possession of the property, together with interest on such profits.

Illustration 2:

‘A’ a trespassers, claims B’s house and collects rents. This is Mesne Profits. He digs a bore-well in the land, constructs a group house and gives it for rent. According to definition of mesne profits given in the Code, mesne profits shall not include profits due to improvements made by the person on the property which is in his wrongful possession. In this case A has done improvement by digging a bore well and constructing a group of house. Hence B can claim for rent collected by A from B’s house as mesne profits but he cannot claim the profits from well and newly constructed group of house as mesne profits.

Illustration 3:

‘A’ (Mortgagee) has mortgaged his property to ‘B’ (Mortgagor). An order of foreclosure of the mortgage and decree of redemption is passed, but ‘B’ does not give possession to ‘A’. Then the profit earned by B using this property or he can earn with due diligence is mesne profits. Hence A has right to claim for the profits which have been received by B from the unlawful possession of the property, together with interest on such profits.

Thus “Mesne profits” are the profits, which the person in wrongful possession actually earned or might have earned with the ordinary diligence.

In Purificacao Fernandes v. Hugo Vincente de Perpetuo Socorro Andhrade, AIR 1985 Bom. 202 case, the Court observed that the Mesne profits are nothing but a compensation that a person in the unlawful possession of others property has to pay for such wrongful occupation to the owner of the property.

In Nataraja Achari v. Balambal Ammal, AIR1980 Mad 222 case, taking into consideration the definition of mesne profits provided under Section 2(12) the Madras High Court observed that there are three different types of cases in which question of rights of profits arise:

• Suit for ejectment or recovery of possession of immovable property from a person in possession without title, together with a claim for past or past and future mesne profits.
• A suit for partition by one or more tenants in common against others with a claim for account of past or past and future profits.
• Suits for partition by a member of joint Hindu family with a claim for an account from the manager.

The Court observed, “In the first case, the possession of the defendant not being lawful, the plaintiff is entitled to recover mesne profits such profits being really in the nature of damages. In second case the possession and receipt of profits by the defendant not being wrongful the plaintiffs remedy is to have an account of such profits making all jus allowance in the favour of the collecting tenant in common. In the third case the plaintiff must take the joint family property as it exists at the date of the demand for partition and is not entitled to open up past account or claim relief on the ground of past inequality of enjoyment of the profit, except where the manager has been guilty of fraudulent conduct or misappropriation. The plaintiff would however, be in the position of the tenant in common from the date of severance in status and his right would have to be worked out on that basis.”

Object s of Mesne profits:

The right to possession is a sacred right guaranteed to all law-abiding citizens. We have to understand that in this case the rightful owner is deprived of his possession and at the same time he is deprived of the income he can obtain from such possession.  The fundamental object of passing Mesne Profit Is to compensate the actual owner of the property for all the loss he has suffered. Thus the mesne profits are compensation paid to the real owner.

In Lucy kochuvareed v. P Mariappa gounder, AIR 1979 SC 1214 , the Court observed that the object of awarding a decree for mesne profits is to compensate the person who has been kept out of possession and deprived of enjoyment of his property even though he was entitled to possession thereof.

Mesne Profits- against whom means profits can be ordered?

Generally, Court can award Mesne Profits against the following persons:

• Tenants in a suit for recovery of possession. (Anderson wright v. Amar Nath Roy, AIR 2005 SC 2457)
• Persons against whom a decree for possession of the immovable property was passed. (Gopal Krishna Pillai v. Meenakshi Ayal, AIR 1967 SC 155)
• Trespass (Sita Ram Lakshmanji v. Dipnarain Mandal, AIR 1977 SC 1870)
• Mortgagors in possession of mortgaged property against whom a decree for foreclosure was passed. (Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Santhosh Kumari, AIR 2008 SC 171)
• Mortgagors in possession of the property after a decree for redemption was passed. (Prabhakaran v. M. Azhagiri Pillai, AIR 2006 SC 1567) .

Conditions for Claiming Mesne Profits:

• There should be a wrongful or unauthorized possession of a property
• A person possessing the property is getting some profit out of the property or can obtain profit from such property with ordinary diligence.

Wrongful possession of the defendant is the essence of a claim for mesne profits and very foundation of the defendant’s liability therof.

In Mohadei v. Kaliji Birajman, 1969 All LJ 896 case, the Court held that the expression ‘mesne profits’ as defined in Section 2(12) of the Code means those profits which a person in wrongful possession of such property either actually received or might have received with due diligence. It is not always necessary that there should be proof of actual receipt.

It is plaintiff’s responsibility to lead evidence to prove the compensation defendant may have received due to illegal possession. In the absence of such proof the Court may reject the plaint for mesne profits.

In Kishen Kumar Narayandas Jobanputra v. Purushottam Mathuradas Raithatha, 2006 (2) Civil Court cases 600 (Bom) case, where the plaintiff did not lead any evidence, it was held that he was not entitled to claim mense profits.

In Lucy kochuvareed v. P Mariappa gounder, AIR 1979 SC 1214 , where the plaintiff is dispossessed by several persons. The Court held that all the trespassers are jointly and severally liable, leaving them to have their respective rights adjusted in a separate suit for contribution, or, may ascertain and apportion the liability of each of them.

What does Mesne Profit Include?

Mesne profit includes theprofits received by him or might have been received by him with ordinary diligence; and the interest on such profits. The rate of interest payable is not fixed and it depends upon the discretion of the court subject to the limitation that it may not exceed 6% per annum. The determination of the amount rests entirely at the discretion of the court and it is difficult to lay down fixed principles which can be applied in every case.

In Mahant Narayana Dossjee Varu vs The Board of Trustees, Tirupati Devasthanam, AIR 1959 AP 64 case, the Court held that under the express terms of the definition, mesne profits are profits received by a person in wrongful possession and they are made up of two items

• The profits received by him or might have been received by him with ordinary diligence; and
• The interest on such profits.

Mesne Profits Includes Interest on Such Profit:

Mense profits includes interest on such profits and interest shall be allowed when computing the mesne profits.

In Mahant Narayana Dasjee Varu v. Tirupathi Devasthanam, AIR 1965 SC 1231 case, the Court observed that the Code of Civil Procedure 1882, for the first time, included interest in the definition of mesne profits. It was rightly done because interest is an integral part of mense profits and has therefore, to be allowed while computing items.

In Kalidas Bakshit v. Saraswati Dasi, AIR 1943 Cal 1 (11) case, the suit was for possession and for mesne profits. After the preliminary decree was passed, there was an enquiry into mesne profits under Order 20, Rule 12, CPC. It was argued that interest should not be awarded. Mitter J. observed: “We do not see why the plaintiff should not get interest. Interest is a part of mesne profits.”

Assessment of Mesne Profit:

In Fateh Chand v. Balkrishna Dass, AIR 1963 Sc 1405 (1412-13) case the Court observed that the mesne profits are in the form of damages, no invariable rule governing their award and assessment in every case can be laid down and the Court may mould it according to the justice of the case.

In Granish vs. Soshi Skildar (MP) case, the court held that the mesne profits are due from the moment possession is wrongfully held by the defendant an interest on such mesne profit is due from the day on which each instilments becomes due. A decree which is salient as to interest must, be taken to mean that mesne profit shall carry interest on them.

In P. L. Kapur v. Jia Rani, AIR 1973 Del 186 case, the Court observed that the criteria for calculation of mesne profits is not what owner loses by reason of deprivation from possession but what trespasser received or might have received with ordinary diligence.

In Sri Ramnik Vallbhdas Madhvani v. Taraben Pravinlal Madhvani, (2004) 1 SCC 497 , the Supreme Court held that A mistake has been committed by the High Court in calculation of interest on mesne profits. Interest has to be calculated on yearly basis because the amount of mesne profits on which interest is to be awarded has to be arrived at on year to year basis. It keeps adding on from year to year. Interest cannot be allowed on the whole amount form the beginning. Interest had to be worked out on amounts falling due towards mesne profits on yearly basis i.e. on the amount of mesne profits which could be taken to be due to the plaintiff at the end of each successive year.

In Gray v. Bhagumian, (1939) 57 I.A. 105 case where the person in wrongful possession planted indigo for use in his adjacent factory and it was proved that an ordinary farmer would have grown sugarcane, wheat or tobacco, their Lordships of Privy Council assessed mesne profits on the profits of cultivation of those more profitable crops.

Deductions from Mesne Profits:

The Court must allow the following deductions from the gross profit of the defendant in possession of the property:-

• The charge for collecting rent, etc.
• The costs of cultivating and reaping the crops, and
• Public charges made from the preservation of the property, e.g., Government revenue.

In Dakshina v. Saroda, ILR (1894) 21 Cal 142 (PC) case, the Court held that while awarding mesne profits, the Court may allow deductions to be made from the gross profits of the defendant in wrongful possession of the property, such as land revenue, rent, cesses, cost of cultivation and reaping, the charges incurred for collection of rent, etc. In other words, mense profits should be net profits.

Types of Cases in which Question of Rights of Profit Arises:

• Suit for ejection  or recovery of possession of immovable property from a person in possession without title, together with a claim for past or past and future mesne prof
• A suit for possession by one or more tenants in common against others with a claim for account of past or past and future profits.
• Suits for possession by number of Joint Hindu Family with a claim for an account from the manager.

Principals to be Applied to Award Mesne Profits:

The Court must apply the following settled principles to award mesne profits:-

• the profit to be taken into account is that made by a person in wrongful possession;
• the aim should be restoration of status before dispossession of the Decree-holder;
• the use to which the decree-holder may have put the property if he himself was in possession is relevant only as evidence of what the defendant might with reasonable diligence have received.

Provisions in the Limitation Act:

The defendant is liable for all mesne profits received by him or which he might with ordinary diligence have received during the 3 years before suit and not before Section 109 of the limitation Act.

Conclusion:

Mesne profits are profits to which a person is entitled but from, which he has been kept out by the defendant. A claim for mesne profits is usually joined with the action for recovery of the possession of the land. The relevant provision of law concerned with mesne profits are a) Section 2(12) of C.P.C. and b) Order 2, Rule 4, and order 20 Rule 12 of C.P.C. The fundamental object of passing Mesne Profit Is to compensate the actual owner of the property for all the losses he has suffered. Mesne profit includes the profits received by him or might have been received by him with ordinary diligence, and the interest on such profits. The criteria for calculation of mesne profits is not what the owner loses by reason of deprivation from possession but what the trespasser received or might have received with ordinary diligence. Mesne profits are in the nature of damages and the right to sue for mesne profit is the right to sue for damages. Such a right cannot be attached and sold in execution of a decree against the person entitled to the decree under section 60.

• Tags (1939) 57 I.A. 105 , (2004) 1 SCC 497 , 1969 All LJ 896 , 2006 (2) Civil Court Cases 600 (Bom) , AIR 1943 Cal 1 (11) , AIR 1959 AP 64 , AIR 1963 Sc 1405 (1412-13 , AIR 1967 SC 155 , AIR 1973 Del 186 , AIR 1977 SC 1870 , AIR 1979 SC 1214 , AIR 1985 Bom. 202 , AIR 2005 SC 2457 , AIR 2006 SC 1567 , AIR 2008 SC 171 , AIR1980 Mad 222 , Anderson wright v. Amar Nath Roy , Assessment of mesne profits , Code , Code of Civil Procedure , CPC , Dakshina v. Saroda , Deduction from mesne profits , Fateh Chand v. Balkrishna Dass , Gopal Krishna Pillai v. Meenakshi Ayal , Granish vs. Soshi Skildar (MP) , Gray v. Bhagumian , ILR (1894) 21 Cal 142 (PC) , Interest on mesne profits , Kalidas Bakshit v. Saraswati Dasi , Kishen Kumar Narayandas Jobanputra v. Purushottam Mathuradas Raithatha , Lucy kochuvareed v. P Mariappa gounder , Mahant Narayana Dossjee Varu vs The Board of Trustees , Mesne profits , Mohadei v. Kaliji Birajman , Nataraja Achari v. Balambal Ammal , Objects of mesne profits , Order 2 Rule 4 , Order 20 Rule 12 , Ownership , P. L. Kapur v. Jia Rani , Prabhakaran v. M. Azhagiri Pillai , Purificacao Fernandes v. Hugo Vincente de Perpetuo Socorro Andhrade , Section 2(12) , Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Santhosh Kumari , Sita Ram Lakshmanji v. Dipnarain Mandal , Sri Ramnik Vallbhdas Madhvani v. Taraben Pravinlal Madhvani , Tirupati Devasthanam

2 replies on “Mesne Profits”

excellent notes made with due diligence.

excellent notes, really helpful

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *